Santa Fe New Mexican

Of course, I believe each and every one of them

- Bret Stephens

Ibelieve Valerie Plame, the former CIA operative and fading liberal celebrity, when she says she missed the antiSemiti­c “undercurre­nts” in an article she called “provocativ­e, but thoughtful.” I believe her when she says she “zeroed in on the neocon criticism” but missed the article’s more prejudicia­l elements.

The article was titled “America’s Jews Are Driving America’s Wars.” It uses variants of the word “Jew” 22 times. The word “neocons” appears only twice. I believe Plame is telling the truth when she says the subtlety was lost on her.

I believed Donald Trump when he insisted last year there was nothing amiss with him tweeting the image of a six-pointed star superimpos­ed over a pile of $100 bills alongside a picture of Hillary Clinton and the caption “Most corrupt candidate ever!” I believe him when he said it was a sheriff ’s star, not a Star of David.

I did not believe white supremacis­t David Duke when he said there was “no way” it was a sheriff ’s star. What does David Duke know about dog whistles anyway?

I believe the National Council of the American Studies Associatio­n was taking an “ethical stance” when it voted unanimousl­y in 2013 for an academic boycott of Israeli institutio­ns. I find nothing askance in the associatio­n never previously boycotting the institutio­ns of any other country. I believe the group’s then-president, Curtis Marez, made a valid argument that Israel was targeted because “one has to start somewhere.”

I believe the American Studies Associatio­n one day will get around to boycotting the academic institutio­ns of China for its occupation of Tibet, or of Russia for its occupation of Ukraine, or of India for its alleged occupation of Kashmir. I believe there’s nothing discrimina­tory in singling out the Jewish state for behavior the American Studies Associatio­n accepts from other states.

I believed then-Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadineja­d when he said, at a New York breakfast I attended in 2010, that anti-Semitism is mostly unknown in his country. I believe that the Islamic Republic is welcoming toward its Jews, as evidenced by the one seat it reserves in its Parliament for a Jew.

I believe there’s nothing antiSemiti­c in calling for Israel to be wiped off the map. I believe Iranian leaders are only interested in historical scholarshi­p and artistic freedom when they hosted a conference for Holocaust deniers or supported Holocaust cartoon contests. I believe a Jewish community in Iran that has experience­d mass emigration since the Iranian revolution is happy with its political masters.

I believed there was nothing amiss with former Republican Senator Chuck Hagel remarking in 2006 that “the Jewish lobby intimidate­s a lot of people” on Capitol Hill. I believe the Jewish lobby must be uniquely intimidati­ng to American lawmakers, unlike, say, the National Rifle Associatio­n or the agricultur­e lobby.

I believe Hagel had nothing to apologize for in the remark for which he later apologized during his confirmati­on process for secretary of defense. I believe Hagel’s apology was sincere.

I believe his apology for opposing James Hormel’s nomination as Bill Clinton’s ambassador to Luxembourg — Hagel slammed Hormel as “openly, aggressive­ly gay” — was also sincere.

I believe the thesis of The Israel Lobby, the 2007 book by Stephen Walt and John Mearsheime­r, is a sound one.

The idea that a small group of (largely) Jewish-Americans manipulate­s Congress, the media and other levers of power and influence for the benefit of a malign Jewish state has no connection to previous antiSemiti­c conspiracy theories alleging the same thing.

I believe that when Jeffrey Goldberg called the book’s ideas “awfully close to the Elders of Z” in a devastatin­g review, his views must be treated as suspect. Who does Goldberg work for, anyway?

I believe that when Mel Gibson said, in the course of a drunken driving arrest, “The Jews are responsibl­e for all the wars in the world,” he meant it as a statement of hearty approval.

I believe that there is nothing curious in the constant ascription of authorship of the 2003 invasion of Iraq to Paul Wolfowitz and Doug Feith, both second-tier officials in the Bush Administra­tion, and Richard Perle, who oversaw a federal advisory committee with no real power.

I believe they were much more influentia­l to the decision-making process than Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, Condoleezz­a Rice, Colin Powell or George W. Bush.

I believe the fact that Wolfowitz, Feith and Perle happen to be Jewish does not, in any sense, make them convenient villains in that drama.

I believe that when left-wing German terrorist Wilfried Böse insisted, during the 1976 hijacking of an Air France jetliner, “I’m no Nazi! I’m an idealist,” he had a point. Böse and his partner, Brigitte Kuhlmann, separated the passengers between Israelis and non-Israelis, freeing the latter while holding the former hostage at Entebbe airport, Uganda, before their rescue by Israeli troops.

I believe that targeting Jews for being Jews is anti-Semitism, but targeting Israelis for being Israelis is a legitimate form of political resistance. I believe anti-Zionism has nothing to do with anti-Semitism.

I believe calling for the eliminatio­n of the Zionist entity is a morally legitimate idea.

Another thing: I believe Valerie Plame when she writes, “Just FYI, I am of Jewish descent.” I believe some of her best friends are Jewish.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States