Santa Fe New Mexican

◆ CDC’s request for personal informatio­n on vaccine recipients raises privacy concerns.

- By Sheryl Gay Stolberg

WASHINGTON — The Trump administra­tion is requiring states to submit personal informatio­n of people vaccinated against COVID19 — including names, birth dates, ethnicitie­s and addresses — raising alarms among state officials who fear that a federal vaccine registry could be misused.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is instructin­g states to sign so-called data use agreements that commit them for the first time to sharing personal informatio­n in existing registries with the federal government. Some states, such as New York, are pushing back, either refusing to sign or signing while refusing to share the informatio­n.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo of New York warned that the collection of personal data could dissuade immigrants without legal status from participat­ing in the vaccinatio­n program. He called it “another example of them trying to extort the state of New York to get informatio­n that they can use at the Department of Homeland Security and ICE that they’ll use to deport people.”

Administra­tion officials say that the informatio­n will not be shared with other federal agencies and that it is “critically necessary” for several reasons: to ensure that people who move across state lines receive their follow-up doses; to track adverse reactions and address safety issues; and to assess the effectiven­ess of the vaccine among different demographi­c groups.

At a briefing with a small group of reporters Monday, officials from Operation Warp Speed, the government’s vaccine initiative, defended the plan. They said all but a handful of states had signed data agreements, and the rest would sign by the end of the week, although it is not clear how many states will submit personal informatio­n.

“There is no Social Security number being asked for; there is no driver’s license number,” said Deacon Maddox, who runs the operation’s data and analysis system. “The only number I would say that is asked is the date of birth.”

A spokesman for the White House, Michael Bars, said the informatio­n “would only be used to support the unpreceden­ted private-public partnershi­p,” including the military, that the administra­tion has deployed “to combat the coronaviru­s and save lives.”

But the hurried effort at data gathering, with delivery of vaccine doses expected to begin next week, is making many immunizati­on experts — including the doctor who ran the CDC’s immunizati­on program for 16 years — deeply uneasy. At issue is the delicate balance between a patient’s right to privacy and the government’s right to invoke its expansive authority in the name of ending the deadliest pandemic in more than a century.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States