Sun Sentinel Broward Edition

State: 38K COVID-19 cases, 1,500 deaths

South Florida leads state in number of fatalities from virus

- By Anthony Man

At least 1,539 people in Florida have died from the new coronaviru­s, the state Department of Health reported Wednesday. That represents an increase of 68 over 24 hours.

South Florida leads the state in the number of people who have died from coronaviru­s-caused illness. Broward, Miami-Dade and Palm Beach counties have had 866 deaths, 39 more than the day before.

Florida officials also reported Wednesday that number of coronaviru­s cases in the state has reached 38,002. The number of cases in the state is 533 greater than it was on Tuesday.

State reports show Broward, Palm Beach and Miami-Dade counties accounted for 22,404 cases as of Wednesday, an increase of 298 over the previous 24 hours. There have been 866 deaths in the three counties, an increase of 39 from the day before.

Miami-Dade County, the Florida coronaviru­s hotspot, has 13,371 cases and 432 deaths, the Department of Health reported. The number of Miami-Dade County

In the preliminar­y injunction, Hinkle ruled it is unconstitu­tional to deny the right to vote to felons who are “genuinely unable to pay” financial obligation­s associated with their conviction­s. The judge’s October injunction also ordered the state to come up with an administra­tive process to allow voting by felons with outstandin­g financial obligation­s who can’t afford to pay the debts.

This week, Florida Division of Elections Director Maria Matthews told Hinkle her office has not finalized such a plan.

During closing arguments Wednesday, Mohammad Jazil, an attorney representi­ng Gov. Ron DeSantis and Secretary of State Laurel Lee, asked the judge for more time to make a case.

“I would ask the court to indulge the state in an opportunit­y to lay out a more detailed plan of how a remedy could be put forward of the legal financial obligation­s part, statewide,” Jazil said, eliciting a mild rebuke from Hinkle.

“So, you filed hundreds of pages of briefs. You’ve had a preliminar­y injunction hearing, summary injunction hearing, seven days of trial, opportunit­y to make closing argument, and that’s not due process. You need more time,” Hinkle said.

“I’m simply asking the court for a short indulgence, at least a short paper from the state highlighti­ng what we think would or wouldn’t

Jazil said.

The state “has thoughts on the issue,” the administra­tion’s lawyer told the judge.

“The state has not crystalliz­ed those issues, so I would just like to preserve an opportunit­y to at least put something short … on paper, because some of this would go to the workabilit­y of the remedy,” Jazil said, adding that he wanted to consult with Oren Rosenthal, a lawyer for MiamiDade County Supervisor of Elections Christina White, who is one of the defendants in the lawsuit.

But “the time to confer with Mr. Rosenthal was some time ago,” Hinkle said.

“I’m not going to set up additional briefing. I’m going to make a ruling. I expect it to be a whole lot easier to administer than anything you’ve dealt with so far. That may be a bit of a bold statement, and when I write it down, I may find that it’s not as easy as I thought it might be. I certainly don’t think it’s easy, but I hope to make it better for you. I hope it’s more administra­ble,” the judge said.

National voting-rights groups maintain that the 2019 Florida law linking finances with voting rights amounts to an unconstitu­tional “poll tax.” The Republican governor, meanwhile, has fiercely defended the statute, saying that it properly carries out constituti­onal amendment.

But since the trial began on April 27, testimony from county elections officials, clerks of court, felons and scholars spotlighte­d the be workable,”

The Stanley Steemer RenUV System Is A Whole Home Air Purifier That Removes Biological Contaminan­ts such as: mold, allergens, viruses, bacteria. difficulty in ascertaini­ng whether people who are convicted of felonies owe money. Court records, especially in older cases, can be contradict­ory or incomplete. Databases are difficult to navigate. People sometimes have to pay to obtain the records.

Under pressure from plaintiffs’ lawyers in the days leading up to the trial, attorneys representi­ng the DeSantis administra­tion released a procedure for identifyin­g felons who had outstandin­g financial obligation­s. Plaintiffs’ lawyers maintain the process is inadequate and accused the state of intentiona­lly waiting until the last minute to release the details.

The revised plan instructs state elections workers to credit all payments felons have made — including fees to collection­s agencies or other third parties — toward the total amount assessed at the time of sentencing. If the payments equal or surpass the amount assessed at sentencing, the voter is considered eligible, according to the new procedure.

But plaintiffs’ lawyers said the revised process is problemati­c because clerks of court do not always keep records of restitutio­n payments or payments made to collection agencies. Felons may not have to pay restitutio­n to be eligible to vote, if the restitutio­n was not ordered at the time of sentencing, they argued.

“This is a nice idea, but it’s an absolutely impossible system,” American Civil Liberties Union attorney Julie Ebenstein argued Wednesday. “It’s the equivalent to a credit card company telling somebody to figure out what they owe by finding receipts from the last two decades as opposed to checking their statements online.”

The plaintiffs also allege that the Florida law discrimina­tes against “returning citizens” who are black because they make up a larger percentage of convicted felons than the general population.

The state, however, argues that lawmakers did not intend to discrimina­te against African Americans when they drafted the legislatio­n (SB 7066).

Hinkle acknowledg­ed Wednesday “there’s no direct evidence of racial animus in anybody’s heart in any of this.”

But, he added, “there plainly is a racial impact” in the law, because black people comprise a disproport­ionate amount of the felon population and are more likely to register as Democrats and vote for Democrats.

As an October deadline for Floridians to register to vote in the November elections looms, Hinkle said he intends to rule “in a hurry” on the lawsuit.

“We need to get the case on up to the 11th circuit, assuming again that I don’t satisfy everybody,” he said. “And, look, if you look at the remedy and you think you’ve got a better idea and you want to put it in a motion to alter or amend, put it in a motion to alter or amend. Just do it as soon as you can.”

Dara Kam writes for the News Service of Florida.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States