Sun Sentinel Palm Beach Edition
Trump criticizes Democrat senator
President says Dem misconstrued court nominee’s statement
Richard Blumenthal misconstrued high court nominee’s statement about his tweet disparaging other judges, president says.
WASHINGTON — In the short history of the Trump presidency, the nomination of Judge Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court had been the one effort operating under traditional rules — smooth, carefully planned and predictable. Until Thursday. The disruption came, as has so often been the case, with a tweet from the president, in which he attacked a senator whose support Gorsuch was trying to win.
As Trump repeated his attack later in the day, White House aides seemed to struggle to keep his comments from complicating what had been a textbook rollout of a high court nomination.
At stake are the votes of a handful of senators who make the difference between an easy confirmation for Gorsuch and a highly partisan one that would require changing the Senate’s rules to obtain a win.
Gorsuch has a firm hold on all 52 Republicans in the Senate. He’s been trying to woo a handful of Democrats in hopes of reaching the 60 votes needed to avoid a filibuster. Part of his approach has been to assure them that if he is confirmed, he would be independent of the man who picked him.
On Wednesday, Gorsuch met with one of the uncommitted Democrats, Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut. Gorsuch told Blumenthal that he was “disheartened” by disparaging statements Trump had made about judges. Trump has aimed his attacks at the judges who have been considering legal challenges to his temporary ban on travelers from seven predominantly Muslim countries.
Blumenthal quickly made the remark public, noting later that Gorsuch had said he was free to do so. A spokesman for Gorsuch confirmed the remark to reporters.
Thursday morning, the former senator who is guiding Gorsuch through the nomination process confirmed the words, again.
“He said that he finds any criticism of a judge’s integrity and independence disheartening and demoralizing,” former Sen. Kelly Ayotte said in a statement. Gorsuch was not commenting on any specific case and emphasized that he was troubled by any attack on the judiciary, she said.
Senate aides and others familiar with the confirmation process interpreted the comments as a careful effort to distance the nominee just far enough from Trump’s controversial remarks to win over the Democratic votes he wants.
The White House team shepherding Gorsuch’s nomination appeared to be trying to give Democrats a “justification for voting for him,” said James Manley, who served as a top aide to former Sen. Harry Reid of Nevada when he was the chamber’s Democratic leader.
But if that was the plan, Trump, sensitive to criticism, complicated it.
In a tweet Thursday morning, he took a shot at Blumenthal, saying the senator had misrepresented Gorsuch’s comments. For good measure, the president also took aim at Blumenthal’s credibility, bringing up a 7-year-old controversy over his military service.
“Richard Blumenthal, who never fought in Vietnam when he said for years he had (major lie), now misrepresents what Judge Gorsuch told him?” Trump tweeted.
During Blumenthal’s campaign for Senate in 2010, he was criticized for claiming in speeches that he had served in Vietnam. Blumenthal had been in the Marine Corps Reserve and was not posted overseas. He later said he had misspoken about his record a few times out of the hundreds of speeches he has given in his political career.
A few hours later, in a White House meeting with several senators, Trump repeated that criticism.
“His comments were misrepresented. And what you should do is ask Sen. Blumenthal about his Vietnam record that didn’t exist after years of him saying it did,” Trump told reporters.
The sequence of events generated multiple theories about what was taking place behind the scenes: Had Gorsuch’s comments caught the White House by surprise or, as many Democrats speculated, had they been part of the administration plan all along?
Manley said he leaned toward the simple explanation — that even if some administration officials knew that Gorsuch would try to distance himself from Trump, the president “did what comes naturally, lashing out” at criticism.
“I think the guy can’t help himself,” he said.
Trump didn’t say how Blumenthal had “misrepresented” Gorsuch’s comments.
But in the daily White House briefing, press secretary Sean Spicer insisted that Gorsuch had been speaking only about “his general philosophy about the judiciary,” not about any specific criticisms Trump had made about judges.
“There is a big difference between commenting on the specific comments that had been made in a tweet and his general philosophy about the judiciary and his respect for his fellow judges,” Spicer said.
“As a whole, he doesn’t like attacks, in general, on the judiciary.”
That interpretation might have assuaged the president’s feelings, but it undermined whatever effort Gorsuch might have been making to demonstrate independence. It gave Democratic leaders an opening to step up demands that he more explicitly denounce Trump’s comments.
A private criticism “whispered” to a senator is “not close to a good enough show of independence,” Democratic leader Sen. Charles Schumer of New York said in a Senate speech.
Gorsuch’s remarks so far were “not a good start,” he added.