Study: Region’s racial attitudes can affect police decisions
When more white people in a community hold African-Americans in greater suspicion, that prevailing view may influence police behavior in ways that drive the outsize use of lethal force against African-Americans by cops, a recent study shows.
It’s a finding likely to stir controversy and spark new interest in the phenomenon of implicit bias—the beliefs and prejudices we hold beneath our level of awareness.
Studied and measured by psychologists since the early 1990s, these unconscious views—which sometimes conflict with the opinions we explicitly embrace—are thought to shape our behavior every day. That influence may be subtle, psychologists say. But it’s never more powerful than when we are under extreme stress or time pressure, as police officers often are.
For the study, a trio of psychologists built a map of the racial bias and stereotypes that prevail among whites across the United States.
They gathered individuals’ answers to a pair of online tests that measure implicit bias and stereotypes about black and white people. Then they arranged them in geographical clusters according to the recorded location of the test-taker.
When the researchers overlaid those maps with their hot spots of white racial bias and presumption of violent intent against African-Americans, they discerned a strong correlation with a very different map: one showing where, in the first nine months of 2015, African-Americans were killed by police in disproportionate numbers.
The study, published last month in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science, was conducted by psychologists Eric Hehman of Ryerson University and Jessica K. Flake of York University, both in Toronto, and by University of California, Davis, social psychologist Jimmy Calanchini.
It relied upon millions of individuals’ scores on online tests taken between 2003 and 2013. Those quizzes use word associations and time pressure to capture beliefs and associations that people hold and make without always being aware of those biases.
The researchers also used a database of people killed by police in the United States (called “The Counted”) that has been compiled by the Guardian newspaper since the start of 2015.
The team considered two measures of community belief: implicit racial bias and a stereotyped view that black people are more threatening than whites.
They found that the latter was a better predictor of disproportionate police killings of black people. When many more white people in a given community revealed in tests that they considered black people more threatening than whites, that community was more likely to have rates of lethal force against black people that were out of proportion to their numbers in the local population.
“The idea here is that context influences behavior,” Hehman said. Our behavior is shaped not just by our own beliefs, he said, but by beliefs that are dominant in a community.
“We’re tapping into that and finding the associations,” he added.
Researchers have long believed that demographic factors—such as poverty, high crime and employment rates, and a preponderance of idle young men—are the most powerful drivers of police officers’ use of lethal force.
Because black communities typically have higher rates of all those factors, outsize rates of police killings in those communities are to be expected, many believe.
The new research does not cast doubt on that explanation. But it does offer evidence that a psychological factor—prevailing racial attitudes in a community and police officers’ embrace of those views—may be a contributor too.