Texarkana Gazette

U.S. decision departs from U.N. resolution­s

- By Rick Gladstone

President Donald Trump’s recognitio­n of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel not only upends decades of American policy. It also appears to put the U.S. at odds with the U.N. Security Council.

The 15-member council has adopted a number of resolution­s, dating back 50 years, aimed in part at preventing Israel from claiming sovereignt­y over all of the holy city.

That could make for awkward diplomatic dynamics on the council, where none of the other members share Trump’s position on Jerusalem.

Eight members, including Britain, France and Italy, allies of the United States, have called for an emergency meeting of the council on Friday to discuss Trump’s declaratio­n.

Many supporters of Israel have long accused the U.N. of bias against it, a criticism that the U.S. ambassador, Nikki R. Haley, has echoed and vowed to change.

As Israel’s strongest ally at the U.N., the U.S. often has used its veto power to block Security Council resolution­s critical of Israel. But there have been exceptions, including for resolution­s concerning the status of Jerusalem.

Here are some notable examples of resolution­s that the U.S. supported or did not block with a veto:

Resolution 242, Nov. 22, 1967: Israel was told to withdraw forces from territorie­s occupied in the 1967 war, which included the eastern part of Jerusalem.

Resolution 252, May 21, 1968: Israel was told to rescind “actions that tend to change the status of Jerusalem,” including the expropriat­ion of land and property.

Resolution 465, March 1, 1980: Israel was warned to stop settlement constructi­on and to disband existing settlement­s in territorie­s occupied in the 1967 war, including Jerusalem. Such acts, the resolution said, amounted to “a flagrant violation” of the Geneva Convention’s protection­s of civilians in wartime.

Resolution 478, Aug. 20, 1980: Israel was censured for having enacted a law declaring a change in the status of Jerusalem, which “constitute­s a violation of internatio­nal law.” Countries that had establishe­d diplomatic missions in the city were called upon to remove them. Resolution 672, Oct. 12, 1990: During the first intifada, or Palestinia­n uprising, Israel was called “the occupying power” in Jerusalem and was condemned over the deaths of more than 20 Palestinia­ns in violence at holy sites in the city on Oct. 8.

Resolution 1073, Sept. 28, 1996:

Israel was warned about archaeolog­ical tunneling near Jerusalem’s holiest site, revered by Jews as the Temple Mount and by Muslims as the Noble Sanctuary. Palestinia­ns were enraged at what they viewed as a sacrilege.

Resolution 1322, Oct. 7, 2000: Israel was condemned over deadly violence arising from a visit to the Temple Mount by Ariel Sharon, then the Israeli opposition leader, which the resolution described as a “provocatio­n” that had led to the deaths of more than 80 Palestinia­ns.

Resolution 1397, March 12, 2002: Both sides were called upon to halt violence and re-engage in peace talks with the goal of a two-state solution, “side by side within secure and recognized borders.” The resolution called on both sides to adopt recommenda­tions of a fact-finding committee, led by the former senator George J. Mitchell, that included a freeze on Israeli settlement­s and cooperatio­n to protect holy sites in Jerusalem and elsewhere.

Resolution 2334, Dec. 23, 2016: Israel was condemned for settlement constructi­on in occupied territorie­s including East Jerusalem. The settlement constructi­on “has no legal validity and constitute­s a flagrant violation under internatio­nal law and a major obstacle to the achievemen­t of the two-state solution,” the resolution said.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States