Valedictorian cut off when speech turns to sexual misconduct

The graduation speech of a California high school 2018 valedictorian was cut off last week when her talk turned to allegations of sexual misconduct on campus.

Lulabel Seitz, 17, the top student at Petaluma High School, posted a YouTube video documenting her speech, and “uncensored version,” which included a line about a campus “in which some people defend perpetrators of sexual assault and silence their victims.” Seitz did not divulge details. “The administration unfairly cut off my mic, and even when my classmates stood up to say that I should speak, they still did not let me finish my speech,” Seitz says in the video. Seitz began her address talking about the hopes and dreams of her classmates and how the school had struggled through a teacher’s strike and was forced to close during a wildfire that swept through Sonoma County last fall. About four minutes into the speech, she mentioned the sexual assault allegations, which were not included in the draft of her address submitted to administrators before the graduation ceremony. That is when her microphone was cut off.

In the video, her classmates can be heard chanting, “Let her speak!”

School officials have declined to comment on the allegations Seitz mentioned in her speech. But the assistant superintendent of student services, Dave Rose, told the Press Democrat that the school was within its legal right to cut off Seitz’s speech, citing a 1998 U.S. Supreme Court case.

“If the school is providing the forum, then the school has the ability to have some control over the message,” Rose told the newspaper.