‘Dark money’ poisons elections

As for “free elections,” recent laws passed by our elected leaders have made it even harder for voters to address their grievances via the ballot box when they encouraged the use of undisclosed contributions, or “dark money,” through super PACs in Arizona elections.

For the most part, undisclosed campaign spending through super PACs is not commonly used to promote a candidate. Instead, it is almost always used to batter and smear the opponents of their preferred candidate.

They are the paid hit squad used to bury an opponent under an avalanche of mud, making a lesser known challenger candidate virtually unelectable in a small turnout primary election.

In 2014, we saw a super PAC come to Secretary of State Michele Reagan’s rescue in the last two weeks of her race against Terry Goddard by attacking his record. We don’t know who funded the attacks. We can only be sure they did not want Goddard elected and that these attacks worked, as Reagan came from behind to win.

Is it any surprise, then, to see Secretary Reagan retreat from her past statements regarding campaign finance transparency and instead work to write and support legislation which loosened the laws on the very dark money groups that contributed to her victory?

Candidates can’t run campaigns

ads talking about his or her opponent.

And of course, a candidate can’t publicly ask a dark money group to stop attacking their opponent. That would be coordination with an outside group and that, of course, is illegal!

Before our Republican partisan friends howl with cries of how their right to free speech would be hindered by more disclosure laws, I would simply remind them that the brightest conservative legal mind of the past century, Justice Antonin Scalia, fell squarely in the camp of more disclosure.

Now that we’ve laid out our state’s electoral process flaws and why this is preventing us from electing leaders that represent all Arizonans, not just 15 percent of us, what should we do?

How do we get more voters?

Here are some simple ideas for our elected officials that we believe will get the ball rolling:

Admit that independent and Party Not Designated voters and candidates are not treated fairly

through our entire electoral process. Gov. Doug Ducey admirably called for the presidential primary election to allow independents to participate in 2016, but we think that should be taken a step further.

If partisan actors want to continue making it nearly impossible for independent candidates to make the ballot or participate in primary elections, they clearly run the risk of a lawsuit challenging equal access to the ballot. Before that, however, they could choose to fix the system.

Stop the flow of taxpayer dollars to private party elections.

As private parties, Republicans and Democrats have the right to choose their preferred candidate through any process they choose; they do not, however, have the right to a private election subsidized by taxpayers, who may themselves be barred from participating.

The state’s Constitution prohibits gifts to private parties that do not promote the public good. So again, before you get sued, change the primary system and give every candidate equal access regardless of party affiliation.

Put the power back in the hands of the candidates.

Introduce legislation similar to the bill introduced in Congress by Sen. Ted Cruz earlier this year called “The SuperPAC Elimination Act of 2017.”

This legislation would eliminate caps on individual and group contributions to candidates and require disclosure of any contribution within 24 hours, putting candidates in control of and responsible for their message and increasing transparency for voters.

Of course, we would improve Senator Cruz’s legislation when a group is the contributor to require disclosure of the “original sources” of the contributions. Republicans will appreciate the removal of limits on free speech, and Democrats will be in favor of more transparency.

Make candidates do their own dirty work.

Samuel Johnson said, “The first step to greatness is to be honest.” So let’s first admit our electoral system no longer represents the people.

Then, let’s do something real that Makes America Great Again by ensuring the integrity of electoral process and guaranteeing equal access to the ballot for everyone regardless of party – our Founding Fathers would be proud.

Chuck Coughlin is the president and founder of HighGround Inc., a public-affairs and consulting firm in Arizona. He served as chairman of Gov. Jan Brewer’s transition team and has run numerous political campaigns in Arizona. Email him at coughlin@azhighground.com.