The Arizona Republic

Sheep mentality versus herd immunity

- Reach Montini at arizonarep­ublic.com. ed.montini@

The New York Times sent a reporter recently to rural Tennessee, an area where the population is predominan­tly white, Christian and Republican, and where the COVID-19 vaccine rate is very low.

The number of Americans who say they aren’t going to get vaccinated has become more and more concerning to public health officials.

The reporter described a scene in which a doctor – a man who nearly died after contractin­g the coronaviru­s – is speaking to an elderly unvaccinat­ed patient.

The man says to the doctor, “How can we be sure there are no chips in the vaccine, like the things you put in your dog?”

“We can’t make microchips that small,” the doctor says.

“Well, it’s like a grain of rice,” says the patient.

The doctor tells him, “I couldn’t inject a grain of rice with a needle.”

The man, according to the report, won’t get the vaccine.

America’s giant pharmaceut­ical companies, with their tremendous resources and their armies of scientists, researcher­s and doctors, have come up with three effective vaccines for COVID-19. It was a scientific miracle for so short a time.

But there is no magic pill, no serum, no medicinal injection capable of warding off ignorance.

So it is unlikely the nation will achieve herd immunity.

A poll commission­ed in February by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs found that as many as 44% of Republican­s said they definitely or probably would not get vaccinated, as did 17% of Democrats.

And there is also the problem of those who might want the vaccine but for whom access is difficult. The homeless, for example.

Kavita Patel, a physician and health policy expert, said, “We could be sitting here in the winter-fall with an entirely different, scary version of the pandemic. One driven by a combinatio­n of variants and people who didn’t want to get vaccinated.”

There is an effort by some members of the Republican political elite to get their constituen­ts vaccinated.

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell said recently, “I can say as a Republican man, as soon as it was my turn, I took the vaccine.”

But the death knell to herd immunity was the skepticism brought on by too many of us taking medical advice from conspiracy kooks, anti-vaxxers, misinforme­d commentato­rs, and a former reality TV personalit­y who resided for a time in the White House.

Back in January, by the way, the former president and the first lady, without a photograph­er present and without alerting the news media, very quietly got vaccinated.

 ?? EJ Montini Columnist
Arizona Republic
USA TODAY NETWORK ??
EJ Montini Columnist Arizona Republic USA TODAY NETWORK

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States