The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Is Trump’s New York security bill higher than cost to fund arts?
Grumbling about the first family’s taxpayer-funded trips and expenses is a time-honored political tradition, no matter the party of the president.
Former President Ronald Reagan’s two-week stay in Santa Barbara, Calif., ran up a Air Force One tab of at least $250,000 in 1981. President Barack Obama’s golf getaways were the subject of constant conservative consternation.
Enter President Donald Trump. People are turning to Trump’s favorite social medium, Twitter, to complain about tax dollars spent protecting first lady Melania Trump and son, Barron, who still live in Trump Tower in New York.
One common comparison we’ve seen says that Melania Trump’s security detail at Trump Tower costs more than the annual budget for the National Endowment for the Arts, which the administration reportedly has considered eliminating altogether.
Here are a sampling of the Tweets making a claim about the cost of New York security for the Trump family relative to the annual cost of the NEA.
Melania Trump staying at Trump Tower instead of the White House:$182,500,000/ year
Budget National Endowment for the Arts:$149,849,000/year
— Tronald V. Dump @TrollnaldDump
The estimated security cost for Melania Trump living 200 miles away from Donald Trump is double the annual budget for the NEA. @NEAarts — Mark Kingsley @markingsley Cost of security detail 4 keeping @MELANIATRUMP in New York is 2x annual budget of @ NEAarts #NationalEndowmentoftheArts @realDonaldTrump — Jose Llana @thejosellana We wanted to know how the argument held up. Problem is, there’s no good number for how much Melania Trump’s New York security detail costs. We’ll start with what we know: The National Endowment for the Arts’ budget was a little under $148 million for fiscal year 2016, and it’s requested a budget of about $150 million for fiscal year 2017, according to its website. To top the 2016 amount, Melania and Barron would need to stay at Trump Tower for an entire year with a detail costing more than $405,000 a day. To beat the 2017 budget request, the security costs would need to exceed $410,000 a day.
During the transition period, the city took on most of the cost of protecting the Trumps in New York. A spokesperson for New
York mayor Bill de Blasio told us Donald, Melania and Barron Trump ran up a $37 million bill for security from Election Day to the inauguration Jan. 20. (De Blasio has requested the federal government reimburse his city for security costs, and Congress has doled about $7 million.)
In comparison, the city of Chicago spent at least $2.2 million to protect Obama’s home in Chicago from his election in November 2008 to his inauguration in January 2009, the Chicago Tribune reported.
CBS’ New York affiliate reported, based on anonymous sources, that the city spends $500,000 a day to protect Trump Tower when the president is there, but less when it’s just Melania and Barron. That figure, de Blasio spokesperson Freddi Goldstein said, likely refers to the daily cost of security ($37 million divided by 74 days).
But the mayor’s office has yet to complete an estimate for the cost of the first lady and Barron’s security detail alone, and believes it’ll be less than $500,000 a day.
Goldstein told us even if the president were visiting New York, the price tag would likely be less today as much of the activity outside Trump Tower has dissipated since the first months of his election.
Trump told reporters in November that his wife and youngest son would join him at the White House “very soon, after he’s finished with school,” which indicates a mid-year move. The White House said this month that Melania Trump will move to the White House at the end of the school year and split time between New York and Washington.
Our ruling
Social media posts say Melania Trump’s security detail at Trump Tower costs more than the annual budget for the National Endowment for the Arts.
That’s a flawed projection based on incomplete data. It assumes that Melania and Barron Trump will stay at Trump Tower the entire year, racking up a security bill of more than $410,000 a day, every day. But officials say that Melania Trump and her son intend to move to the White House at the end of the school year and split time between Washington and New York.
What the first family will actually do we don’t know. But neither do bloggers.
They should back off this claim until there is more data.
We rate it Mostly False.