The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Thanks, Boy Scouts, but the girls enjoy their own thing

- Mary Sanchez She writes for the Kansas City Star.

What indignity will be piled on the Girl Scouts next?

They’ve fought off boycotts of their cookie drives engineered by misguided people who tried to link the stellar organizati­on to abortion and family programmin­g overseas.

Rest assured; the dollars you hand over for Thin Mints do not pay for abortions elsewhere. Those calories are pure.

Like other organizati­ons that serve youth, Girl Scouting has found itself competing for members against a wide variety of other options.

But now they’re up against the Boy Scouts. Hoping to bolster its own falling membership, Boy Scouting is inviting girls to join.

Beginning next year, the younger Cub Scout dens will be able to be either all boys or all girls. And Cub packs can choose to be either all one sex or open to both. Officials even dangled the prospect of girls earning the coveted status of Eagle Scout.

Girls, be prepared — and wary!

Admittedly, a far younger version of me would have been enthused at the prospect becoming an Eagle Scout. What better way for a young girl to illustrate that her abilities and preparatio­n for life as a solid citizen are equal to any boy’s. In my case, there would have been the additional lure of keeping up with two older brothers who earned that illustriou­s rank.

However, there is less here than one might suppose. Girls have nothing to prove by making it in Boy Scouting — and possibly less to gain.

Boy Scouting, after all, is not a male equivalent of Girl Scouting, nor does its programmin­g excel its counterpar­t’s.

It has a different philosophy, lacking the inclusive and forward- thinking ethos that has long defined Girl Scouting.

“Separate but equal” is a rarely achieved standard when it comes to single-sex organizati­ons. In fact, Girl Scouting is somewhat of a stellar anomaly in this regard. But the vitality of the Girls Scouts is on par with, if not ahead of, Boy Scouting.

As an organizati­on, Girl Scouting has remained nimble, flexible, positioned to react to individual girls’ and community needs. The dictates of how a troop can be configured are left to local leadership.

Girl Scouting was not late to react to societal changes such as LGBT rights. It long ago backed off from adherence to codes about faith. Girls can self-define how they want to conceptual­ize the Girl Scout Promise that begins, “On my honor, I will try: To serve God and my country .... ”

In much the same way, Girl Scouting moved into STEM, building new curriculum around robotics and mechanical engineerin­g when it became apparent that more women are needed in those fields.

By comparison, until very recently, Boy Scouting was much more stagnant. It put Boy Scouting at a disadvanta­ge

It took the Boy Scouts until 2013 to end the ban on openly gay members.

Only two years later did it find the tolerance to end the exclusion of gay men from leadership.

And it was only this year that Boy Scouting announced that it would accept transgende­r young people.

Girl Scouting has no patience for such stalling. Frankly, Girl Scouting doesn’t need its male counterpar­t open to our gender.

We’ve got our own organizati­on that is serving the needs of girls and young women just fine, thank you.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States