The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Jury acquits ex-housekeeper in sex tape trial
Decision finally made six years later, but more litigation is pending.
Six years of competing legal maneuvers culminated Wednesday when a Fulton County jury found the ex-housekeeper of the chairman of Waffle House not guilty on charges of unlawful surveillance.
Also acquitted on those same charges were the two attorneys that the former housekeeper, Mye Brindle, had retained for a 2012 civil lawsuit against chairman Joe Rogers Jr.
In a trial that called into question the nuances of Georgia’s privacy laws, Brindle was accused of making a clandestine recording of herself engaging sexually with Rogers in his bedroom in 2012. Because attorneys David Cohen and John Butters had advised Brindle to make the recording, they were also charged.
Unlawful surveillance is a felony that carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison or a $10,000 fine, or both. Cohen and Butters were each charged with one count; Brindle was charged with two. The jury acquitted the three defendants on all charges after two days of deliberation.
Brindle and Rogers regularly had sexual encounters, according to their testimonies.
That sum includes disputed litigation fees. Keith’s attorneys didn’t immediately comment on the settlement.
That lawsuit targeted former GOP Chairman John Padgett, who last summer chose not to seek another term as the state party’s leader. Watson won a tight vote to replace Padgett in part because of a pledge to close the legal case and rev up the party’s fundraising.
In a note last year to supporters, Watson wrote that the “entirety of this debt was inherited from the past administration and is now being reported after reaching finality on a number of unknown debt amounts.”
Keith’s lawsuit claimed she was fired after complaining to her superiors about her co-workers’ behavior, and she sought damages and lost wages under the federal Civil Rights Act. She said her colleagues gossiped about her 2002 felony conviction in Montana, which she said the party was aware of when it hired her in 2013.
The Georgia GOP’s attorney, Anne Lewis, said in 2014 that Keith was fired for “consistently poor job performance.” But the party’s efforts to block the case in court were stymied by a March 2017 ruling by a federal judge that allowed a key part of the racial discrimination lawsuit to move forward.
The lawsuit contributed to the state GOP’s troubles attracting donors amid mounting legal bills. Watson took over a party in June that was deep in debt despite the fact that Republicans dominate state politics and Georgia GOP politicians have no problem raising big money for their own campaigns.
The party’s latest filings show it is chipping away at the debt but hasn’t erased it, despite taking in $833,000 over the past two months.
The party got big checks from traditional donors, such as Georgia Power ($10,000), Flowers Foods ($25,000) and the Republican National Committee ($41,000), along with $52,000 from Duluth gem and jewelry company Bellagem and $50,000 from Athens disaster recovery response company MLU Services.
Still, according to the reports, the party ended March 31 with $376,000 in the bank and owing $512,000 for various services. Much of the debt involves legal bills.
It’s a far cry from the party’s financial position at the beginning of the decade, when it banked huge amounts of money and had the cash to power its slate of candidates.
In 2010 it had about $2 million in the bank, but its fortunes began to decline, reaching a nadir of just $11,403 in December 2015. The party’s finances were a major issue in last year’s chairman’s election, and Watson has vowed to shore up the GOP’s books.
By contrast, the state Democratic Party, which is the minority party in both chambers of the state Legislature and holds no statewide office, reported about $447,000 in the bank as of March 31.