The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Uber Eats driver guilty of murder
Jury needed only three hours to convict Bivines in Feb. 17 shooting death.
It took a Fulton County jury only three hours to convict a former Uber Eats driver of killing his customer.
Robert Bivines was found guilty Friday on multiple murder counts in the February shooting death of Ryan Thornton in Buckhead. Bivines was sentenced to life in prison plus five years on charges of malice murder, felony murder, aggravated assault and possession of a weapon during the commission of a felony.
Bivines, 36, had long claimed he shot and killed Thornton, 30, in self-defense after he was threatened while delivering food to his victim’s condominium on the night of Feb. 17.
“I just want to apologize for everything that occurred. To the family, to the court,” Bivines said in court. “I know my words are useless, so I’m at a loss for words.”
Thornton’s loved ones, including fiancée Jerica Jones, asked Fulton County Superior Court Judge Jerry Baxter to give Bivines the maximum possible sentence. Jones was the first person Thornton called after he was shot.
“This has been overwhelming, but at the end of the day I don’t really believe in the death penalty,” Jones said in court Friday. “(Bivines) took a lifetime from me, a future family... I can only ask that Robert Bivines serve every day for every year of every count he was charged with.”
would raise this year’s overall state budget to about $26.5 billion — would provide $69 million in emergency relief to local and state agencies, $69 million for debris removal, $55 million to assist farmers facing substantial crop losses and damage, $40 million to rebuild and help spur economic growth in the region affected by the storm, $20 million to address recovery and cleanup efforts by timberland owners, $9 million for damaged state facilities and $8.2 million to replace damaged firefighting equipment.
Some of the money would provide matching funds required to obtain federal emergency aid. Other cleanup and repair costs would be paid by the federal government, although state officials say it could be months, if not years, for that money to make it to Georgia.
Senate Appropriations Chairman Jack Hill, R-Reidsville, said it was fortunate that the storm occurred when the state economy was strong. With tax collections way up, he said, the state can afford to help southwest Georgia.
“Timing is so important to start getting relief out there,” she said.
State House Speaker David Ralston, R-Blue Ridge, called it a “very, very good feeling” to pass the hurricane relief bills, saying they send a message to people in southwest Georgia that the state is prepared to help them.
State Rep. Matt Gurtler, R-Tiger, was the only House member to vote against both hurricane relief bills.
“The stated goal was to help by sending funds to counties hardest hit,” Gurtler said Friday. “But, as often with government, not only is it not fit to help, the way we have allocated the help doesn’t fit within its proper role and is not in line with conservative principles. Therefore, I could not support the measure, even though I support the individuals.”
Gurtler noted that lawmakers could have approved the spending without a special session that costs more than $40,000 a day. The General Assembly has a committee of leaders that can handle such requests.
“Not only do we waste tax dollars on bureaucracy with every action, but we also waste tax dollars on the debate on how much of those tax dollars we can spend,” he said.
He called the timber replanting tax break “a subsidy for a portion of the industry, for a limited area, under specific circumstances, and with a whole lot of expensive bureaucracy.”