The Columbus Dispatch

Writer slanted election details

-

Erik Meyer’s Tuesday letter “They are Democrats in name only” made many questionab­le assertions, but I have to take issue with his contention that the Electoral College is democratic and that Republican­s peacefully accept the outcomes of presidenti­al elections when they lose.

The Electoral College is absolutely not democratic. It was created in 1787 as a reaction by the framers to what they perceived as the “excessive democracy” shown by state legislatur­es that had passed debt-relief legislatio­n. It also served to protect the interests of Southern slaveholde­rs, by counting slaves as of a person in order to apportion more voting power to the Southern states.

Meyer’s claim that Donald Trump won a landslide by winning 304 electoral votes to Hillary Clinton’s 227 convenient­ly ignores the results of the popular vote, which Clinton won by 2,868,519 votes. Meyer also failed to mention that almost 54 percent of the country’s votes were cast for someone other than Trump. No other comparable democratic nation in the world employs a device as anachronis­tic as the Electoral College. It is ludicrous for Meyer to claim that “this is how democracy works or is supposed to work.”

But Meyer managed to astonish me with this claim: “When a Democrat wins, the Republican­s do not like it, but quietly accept the outcome.” Did the tea party or Republican­s in Congress quietly accept the election of President Barack Obama? The right wing in this country spent eight years questionin­g Obama’s birth certificat­e, suggested that he was a closeted Muslim, ginned up irrational fear about the Affordable Care Act (remember “death panels”?), falsely accused him of trying to abolish the right to bear arms, shut down the government and threatened to vote against the debt ceiling, while successful­ly obstructin­g Obama’s nominee to the Supreme Court in 2016.

Craig Swarts Columbus

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States