The Columbus Dispatch

2nd Amendment is outdated

-

I respond to the Tuesday letter "Evil hearts are the problem" from Ted Angel, who said it is a “constituti­onal right to own firearms — no restrictio­ns enumerated — for our safety and recreation­al use.” That assertion, although validated more or less via a political decision made by an activist rightwing Supreme Court that ignored original intent, is simply false.

The Second Amendment does have “restrictio­ns enumerated,” a phrase also totally ignored by the rightwinge­rs: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State...” The “original intent,” validated by history that the right-wingers once again totally ignored, was that a citizen militia, which had, at best, a mixed record in the revolution­ary war, could somehow stand up to a repressive government, such as, then, Great Britain.

It is total nonsense now when even the poorest government on earth has access to advanced weapons, and many government­s, including every level of U.S. government, has access to weapons of war, from rifles and tanks, to airplanes and helicopter gunships, to atomic bombs, that anyone with a handgun or even the infamous AR-15 could ever successful­ly oppose those government­s in an armed conflict.

The Second Amendment never was and still is not about “our safety and recreation­al use.” The amendment is, in fact, a historical anachronis­m.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States