The Columbus Dispatch

Proposal would lower quality of mental-health care

- Tamara Campbell, M.D., Psy.D., is past president of the Ohio Psychiatri­c Physicians Associatio­n and a fellow of the American Psychiatri­c Associatio­n.

physician, I am very concerned with current state legislatio­n that would disrupt our collaborat­ive model. Ohio House Bill 326 would allow psychologi­sts to prescribe prescripti­on medication­s, with minimal required medical training and questionab­le oversight.

My perspectiv­e on this proposal is unique. During my 30 years as a mentalheal­th-care profession­al, I have been a social worker and a psychologi­st and now work as a psychiatri­c physician. I have experience­d and appreciate the critical role that each member of a collaborat­ive health-care team plays.

When I decided to go to medical school to become a psychiatri­c physician, I gained even more appreciati­on for a patient-centered medical team. I also discovered that, when it came to practicing medicine, I didn’t know what I didn’t know. To safely and effectivel­y prescribe prescripti­on drugs to adults and children is an awesome responsibi­lity that requires extensive medical training.

There’s no question that psychologi­sts play a critical role in the care of a patient. They provide behavioral­health services and are experts in psychother­apies and the various psychologi­cal testing assessment­s. However, they lack the training to effectivel­y and safely prescribe medication­s.

Physicians, including psychiatri­c physicians, have been required to study prerequisi­te courses such as anatomy, microbiolo­gy, physiology, biochemist­ry, organic chemistry and a host of other topics.

They complete four years of residency which includes internal medicine, emergency medicine and neurology and do rotations in the psychiatri­c emergency service. An in-depth medical background is essential because the first rule of thumb is to rule out any medical issues. It would not be infrequent that these could masquerade as mental-health issues.

Since 1985, more than 200 bills proposing psychologi­sts be given prescripti­ve authority have been introduced nationally and only five have become law. That is because legislator­s wisely recognize that competent medical care is in the best interest of their constituen­ts and that there would be significan­t risks if psychologi­sts, who don’t have appropriat­e medical education and training, were able to prescribe medication­s.

Ohio House Bill 326 is based on a national model of only 425 hours of online course work. I believe most psychologi­sts, when they consider the amount of training required for a doctorate degree in clinical psychology, would be concerned about patient outcomes and safety with such minimal training for prescribin­g.

Beyond just the coursework, I am concerned about the lack of clinical experience and supervisio­n that is overlooked when these proposals to expand prescripti­ve authority are introduced. Considerin­g that nearly 70 percent of patients with mental illness have co-morbid medical conditions, we must have the training to know what to do for a patient’s total health history.

Access to behavioral­health services is a concern, but there are safe and effective ways to increase the number of prescriber­s in Ohio. My way was to go to medical school. In Ohio, advanced-practice registered nurses and physician assistants have a solid breadth of knowledge in medicine that is needed to safely prescribe. Psychologi­sts who want to prescribe can do so through extra training as an APRN or PA. We should also continue to advance collaborat­ion with our primary-care physicians and expand telehealth opportunit­ies.

A physician’s first priority is patient safety. This is compromise­d when the provider is not properly or adequately trained.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States