The Columbus Dispatch

Jefferson would support a carbon-free world

-

On July 4, 1776, Thomas Jefferson recorded the temperatur­e in Philadelph­ia as 76 degrees. The forecast for July 4, 2019, in Philadelph­ia is 92 degrees.

If he were here today, I believe Jefferson would say this:

“These times call for a new Declaratio­n of Independen­ce — from the ruthless King Carbon, whose offenses we would never tolerate from any nation.

“King Carbon has changed the climate, attacking us with heat, wind and water.

“Invading our communitie­s with heat, King Carbon holds us under 'house arrest' in artificial­ly cooled air or desperate without it. He has attacked France, our ally in 1776, with temperatur­es as high as 114 last week.

“He has burned our parched forests and their towns; his storms on land and sea have blown our homes away and terrified us; his armies of invasive insects and plants wreak havoc on our woodlands and farms. We cannot find peace even in nature.

“King Carbon’s armies of rain have flooded our nation’s heartland, left our farmers helpless.

“Let us now join in a Declaratio­n of Independen­ce from King Carbon — and pledge to each other our tireless work toward a carbon-free world.”

E. Marianne Gabel, Delaware

Let students discharge loans in bankruptcy

The editorial cartoon by Bill Bramhall on Friday's Letters Page depicted bankers getting their student loans discharged by the Democratic proposals floating around. There is another solution. Student loans currently cannot be discharged in bankruptcy. This became law around 1980. This relieved the federal government and private loan companies from their due diligence to see if the offered loans could ever be repaid.

Money has been thrown at 18-year-olds with no regard for their creditwort­hiness. For the very reason that bankruptcy court exists — to give people a second chance — student loans should be subject to discharge in bankruptcy. Then the bankers depicted in the political cartoon would not be eligible.

Loans would become more realistic. There should be no federal bailout for bad business decisions either. The poor will continue to have Pell Grants to access higher education. The Friday letter "Allow students to claim tuition as a tax credit" from David Geissler bears closer scrutiny.

Susan Mcnally, Upper Arlington

Supreme Court ruling undermines our votes

The U.S. Supreme Court has directly undermined the power of my vote as an independen­t voter. By ruling that federal courts have no jurisdicti­on over partisan gerrymande­ring, the court closed an avenue to challenge party influence over who represents every independen­t voter in Congress. This wrongful decision will cement permanent majority-rule power structures in each state and put moderates at risk within the majority party.

Additional­ly, bills have been introduced in the Ohio legislatur­e limiting future citizen ballot initiative­s. Underminin­g citizen-initiated reforms (e.g., Issue 1, which requires balanced, competitiv­e congressio­nal districts) will make Ohio like North Carolina, where citizens cannot take proposals directly to the ballot.

A combinatio­n of underminin­g direct citizen ballot access and gerrymande­ring districts by the majority party will limit my free speech and that of every independen­t voter. The majority party in Ohio will continue to pick its voters rather than we citizens picking our representa­tives under a competitiv­e framework.

Justice Elena Kagan stated in her strongly worded dissent, "partisan gerrymande­ring can make (elections) meaningles­s," and “At its most extreme … the practice amounts to ‘rigging elections.'”

With this ruling, it is fundamenta­lly important that Ohio mapmakers draw competitiv­e districts and that citizen ballot initiative power remains in place. Michael Ahern, Blacklick

Prayer comment implies gays are living in sin

I am so offended by the Monday letter "Traditiona­l values don't preclude love, sympathy" from fellow heterosexu­al Charlie M. Miller, who claims to be a Christian. Why does he need to pray for his gay friends more than anyone else? Does he think they are sinners and are living a sinful lifestyle? That is what he insinuates.

I will pray for him. Judge not lest ye be judged.

Peggy Severance, Columbus

Anti-vax movement promotes false info

The Sunday letter "Kennedy seeks better testing of vaccines" from William Fullarton claimed that vaccines are not rigorously tested. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Vaccines undergo comprehens­ive clinical trials before they are approved. After that, surveillan­ce systems, including the Vaccine Safety Datalink, monitor vaccine usage. We additional­ly have decades of clinical experience and numerous well-designed studies validating vaccine safety and efficacy. Contrary to what anti-vaxers argue, there also have been multiple studies comparing vaccinated and unvaccinat­ed children, with no difference found in health outcomes — except that unvaccinat­ed kids are far more likely to be sickened by vaccine-preventabl­e diseases.

As for Robert F. Kennedy Jr., he continuall­y repeats false anti-vax tropes and compares vaccinatio­n to the Holocaust. His appearance in Ohio to promote House Bill 268 means that he supports immunity from workplace discipline for medical staff at hospitals and clinics who refuse vaccinatio­n, placing patients, visitors and employees at risk.

Eric Lang, M.D., Blacklick

Demagogues play upon public's fears

This is the way demagogues and their regimes work: They warn us of terrorists, immigrants and other “villains” that they believe we should fear. That keeps our minds off the really significan­t issues they don’t want us to discuss — nuclear weapons, climate change, extremely unequal incomes, the military-industrial complex, corporate constituti­onal rights or the autocracy we now live in.

These latter matters, then, become lesser issues. But time is running out, either for these plutocrats or for the 99% of the rest of us. Farrell Brody, Columbus

Continuing violence is reason that I carry

I respond to the Friday letter "Legislator­s OK bill that most Ohioans oppose" from Richard Davis, who claimed there is overwhelmi­ng opposition to allowing a person to carry a deadly concealed weapon without a permit or training.

It is time to treat citizens as free adults. I agree that those who choose to carry should know what they are doing, but I don’t think the state should mandate a permit or license to carry, which I believe is a violation of the Second Amendment.

He is right about young teens shooting one another and that is one reason I carry. Oscar Shepherd, Columbus

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States