The Commercial Appeal

‘Dallas’ reboot a sad affair lacking charm of original

- By Kevin Mcdonough

Is America ready for a new “Dallas” (8 p.m., TNT)? Does it want one?

The original debuted in 1978 and all but defined an era of prime -time soap operas that featured overthe -top stories of family betrayal and celebrated conspicuou­s wealth. And with its “Who Shot J.R.?” story line, “Dallas” went into the TV record books for having one of the most anticipate­d cliffhange­r episodes in network TV history. At the time, it was the most-watched episode of any show, winning a whopping 76 percent of the TV audience in spring 1980. But that, as they say, was a long time ago.

Proof that remakes can be sad affairs arrives early in this new “Dallas.” Stars and characters from the old series appear, if only to pass the torch to the next generation of troublemak­ers. Bobby Ewing (Patrick Duffy) gets a cancer diagnosis. J.R. Ewing (Larry Hagman) sits silently in a wheelchair in a nursing home, unresponsi­ve and depressed.

Maybe he’s bummed that his son, John Ross Ewing III (Josh Henderson), is such a meager chip off the old block. He’s first seen operating an oil rig on the Southfork Ranch. (As if nobody would notice.) John Ross seems more impulsive than smart. Good thing he’s got Elena Ramos (Jordana Brewster) around to help. She’s the daughter of a Southfork maid and the former fiancée of John Ross’ cousin and rival, Christophe­r Ewing (Jesse Metcalfe), Bobby’s adopted son. Elena’s also a geological genius, having taught the aggressive John Ross that there could be “billions” of gallons of oil underneath the family compound. Isn’t that convenient?

Christophe­r irks John Ross because he wants out of the oil business. He’s onto a new form of methane extraction that’s got old Bobby excited enough to want to sell Southfork to a land conservanc­y that will preserve its natural splendor forever.

While the dialogue has been updated to include contempora­ry energy jargon about alternativ­e fuels and hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking,” the mechanics of this soap seem as dated as a 1979 Chrysler K-Car. Much is made of an assignment to “steal” informatio­n that turns out to be readily available on the Internet.

The formulaic struggles between idealism and greed

Health and between cousins in love with the same woman may feel like the old “Dallas,” but the young leads are just too generic to carry the torch. John Ross has none of his father’s savvy or wit. Metcalfe’s Christophe­r often acts like he’s just walked in from the set of a Hallmark movie.

The first “Dallas” was hardly a novel idea. In many ways it was a prime - time version of a daytime soap, lifting story lines from 1950s movies such as “Giant” and “Written on the Wind.” Bobby and J.R. were originals, in an obvious, cheesy way. Let them (and “Dallas” viewers) live with their memories. This new version is not so much terrible as forgettabl­e.

Other highlights

Slobber barons on “Dogs in the City” (7 p.m., WREG-TV Channel 3).

Protégés and mentors sing party songs on “Duets” (8:30 p.m., WPTY-TV Channel 24).

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States