The Commercial Appeal

Donald Trump’s bluster and balloons summit

- Wendy R. Sherman Columnist Special to The Commercial Appeal

I supported President Trump’s decision to meet with Kim Jong Un, the dictator of North Korea. From my own experience in negotiatin­g with the North Koreans, I know that their leaders believe only they can make consequent­ial decisions for their country. This makes sense because North Korea lacks a free press, an effective legislatur­e and any sense of “we the people.”

Although the United States is a democracy, President Trump has said that he feels that only he makes decisions for our country.

I thought, then, that perhaps these two leaders might develop a framework that would authorize negotiatin­g teams to move forward with a plan to dismantle North Korea’s nuclear weapons program and ballistic missiles in a complete, verifiable and irreversib­le way.

Instead, the Singapore summit wasn’t much more than bluster and balloons. It was a celebrator­y summit where Kim publicly received the respect and recognitio­n he and his predecesso­rs have long sought, and Trump didn’t get much more than a vague promise.

Optics were arranged to portray Kim as the equal of a U.S. president. Flags of both countries were hung side-by-side, photo-ops were arranged, and the leaders signed a statement that was weaker than at least three previous documents signed by North Korea in years past.

Unlike the agreements negotiated in 1992, 1994 and 2005, Tuesday’s joint statement includes no verificati­on requiremen­ts or framework to guide negotiatio­ns.

To further complicate matters, President Trump announced that the United States would cease joint military exercises with South Korea and indicated that he hopes to withdraw all U.S. troops from the peninsula — removing from the start an important tool in our diplomatic toolbox, in this case deterrence of the North’s large convention­al military.

To make matters worse, the president used North Korea’s talking points, calling the exercises “war games” and “provocativ­e” when they are defensive in nature. And, apparently, the announceme­nt was made without South Korea’s knowledge.

This announceme­nt underscore­s the president’s predilecti­on to act without regard to alliances and partners.

He appears to have forgotten about our unified command with the Republic of Korea, which serves our security as well as South Korea’s, and he doesn’t seem to understand that any potential agreement would be durable only if South Korea, Japan, China and Russia are on board.

Kim no doubt returned home to cheering crowds, organized by his government, heralding him as a great leader who successful­ly made the United States treat North Korea as an equal.

President Trump, too, has turned on the media machine, organizing a political campaign-like rally to herald his summit. It would be better for everyone if these leaders and their teams simply got down to work.

I hope the much-hyped personal touches of the summit lead to a personal best in peacemakin­g for each leader and, more important, for our countries, our partners and the world.

Wendy R. Sherman is a senior counselor at the Albright Stonebridg­e Group, was undersecre­tary of State for political affairs from 2011-15 and led U.S. negotiatio­ns on the Iran nuclear deal. She was policy coordinato­r on North Korea in the Clinton administra­tion.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States