The Denver Post

Is vast condemnati­on of nation’s activity right?

-

pyongyang, north korea» When North Korea claimed triumphant­ly that it had tested its first hydrogen bomb, it was roundly and predictabl­y condemned by the United States, China, Russia, Britain, France and India, countries estimated to possess a combined total of more than 15,000 nuclear warheads.

Non-nuclear powers, too, condemned the test, including Japan, the country that was on the receiving end of the only atomic bomb attack in history.

But while most of the world, East and West, agrees that no one wants North Korea to be an effectivel­y functionin­g nuclear power, a question that can’t be escaped lurks behind the condemnati­on: How much right do nations have to tell other nations what to do? Moreover, how much of a right do nuclear powers, which have no intention of giving up their own arsenals, have to demand others to give up theirs?

North Korea, of course, says none.

In a show of defiance and nationalis­t pride that is so characteri­stic of the North, masses of North Koreans filled Pyongyang’s Kim Il Sung Square on Friday, which happened to also be leader Kim Jong Un’s birthday, to celebrate their military’s new crown jewel. Fireworks and dancing parties were held after the rally.

With its latest test Wednesday, which may or may not have been of an H-bomb — outside expert opinion remains divided — it is treading further down a dangerous, but well-worn, path.

As has been the case with every nation that went nuclear, possession of such weapons is seen by the North’s regime as a strategic necessity. That’s why decades of pleading with and punishing the North simply haven’t worked.

Developing a credible nuclear force is in the long run cheaper for Pyongyang and far more likely to be successful than building and maintainin­g the massive and highly sophistica­ted convention­al forces that would be needed to deter the United States.

Although mega-weapons such as the H-bomb have become largely irrelevant to superpower military planners, who now have the technology to conduct precision attacks that are far more effective and less likely to generate universal condemnati­on, it’s the kind of threat that still works for Pyongyang.

Its self-defense claim is also hardly extraordin­ary.

It has been used by all of the nuclear powers, starting with the U.S., as they developed their arsenals. And, once developed, none has given theirs up.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States