Is America ready for a gay president?
I OWA » The question posed to Pete Buttigieg — gay, married and running for president — came from a supporter at an Iowa campaign stop: What should he tell friends who say America isn’t ready to elect a gay man as president?
That prompted a woman in the crowd to object with an expletive, igniting cheers from hundreds in the audience.
Of the many intriguing things about Buttigieg and his candidacy for president — his Ivy League, Rhodes scholar pedigree and his war service in Afghanistan — a vital question overlaying the 2020 campaign is whether as a gay man his sexual orientation is a barrier to the nation’s highest office.
The first answer will come in Iowa, a state where the 37-year-old South Bend, Ind., mayor has campaigned frequently and spent heavily. So far, Democratic voters here seem to say that Buttigieg’s sexual orientation is immaterial.
“The world will be watching. The activist world. The party world,” said Paul Tewes, who directed Barack Obama’s 2008 Iowa caucus victory, which propelled him to become the nation’s first African-american president. “It would signal to the rest of the world that this stuff doesn’t matter, that people just want him to be president.”
Friday at an LGBTQ forum in Cedar Rapids, Buttigieg framed his experience as a gay man as an advantage.
“There’s a culture of belonging that we need to establish in this country,” he said. “One of the reasons I’m so proud to be a member of this community is because I think we have the power to reach into our own experiences, belonging to a part of America that also cuts across all the other different categories. We could help be that glue.”
Buttigieg also spoke about his own experiences facing discrimination as a gay man, noting the “weight lifted” when the government’s policy barring gay men from serving in the military was reversed. He also described how it felt to host South Bend’s first blood drive and not be able to participate, because of the ban on gay men donating blood.
Buttigieg was one of 10 Democratic candidates to speak at the forum, the first ever focused solely on the issue in a presidential race. The forum itself is a measure of the acceptance gay rights have achieved in the state party and the nation as a whole.
In June, the Iowa Poll by The Des Moines Register and its partners found that 62% of likely Iowa caucus participants said it would make no difference to them for a Trump challenger to be gay. They were more concerned, by 12 percentage points, about a Democratic nominee being over 70 years old.
The age group most likely to disregard the notion of a gay nominee was voters 65 and older, people such as John Sauer, a retired school superintendent from the Cedar Rapids area.
“I have no problem with it,” said Sauer, 71, who showed up at a Buttigieg campaign office opening in Cedar Rapids this month. He and his wife, Elizabeth, say Buttigieg tops their lists of candidates.
Sauer’s feelings — which he described as unheard of in his parents’ generation — speak in part to a decadelong maturing of gay rights in Iowa.
In 2009, Iowa became the first state outside of the East Coast to legalize same-sex marriage, a change implemented by a unanimous state Supreme Court case that came six years before the U.S Supreme Court legalized gay marriage nationally. In 2003, only 23% of Iowans overall supported allowing same-sex marriage.
By 2015, not only did 81% of likely Democratic caucus participants support gay marriage, so did 26% of Republican caucusgoers, the Iowa Poll showed.
“But I do think there are people who might have a problem with it. You can’t get around that,” Sauer said.
That sentiment also registered in the June Iowa Poll, where 28% of likely Democratic caucus participants said being gay would be a disadvantage for a Democratic nominee.
Buttigieg’s profile in the state may not be so out of the ordinary among Iowa’s progressive Democratic caucus electorate, said Jodee Winterhof, Human Rights Campaign’s senior vice president for policy and political affairs.
“That package of things I don’t think is extraordinary to Iowa Democrats,” said Winterhof, a veteran Iowa Democratic campaign strategist and former senior adviser to Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaigns. “I bet you in terms of the questions he gets asked very few of the questions he is asked are about being gay.”
In fact, the question at the crowded outdoor campaign event in August was the only one Buttigieg fielded on his sexuality during the eastern Iowa trip.
Buttigieg’s answer focused on his personal hope of finding a partner after returning from Afghanistan.
“I just had to find the courage that said, either way, I can live with it. But I’ve got to be who I am and trust the voters, based on the job I’ve been doing,” he said, noting that he was overwhelmingly reelected mayor in 2015.
Still, he is not even the unanimous choice in Iowa’s Democratic LGBTQ community. Des Moines lawyer and gay-rights activist Sharon Malheiro, who isn’t supporting Buttigieg, says his age and lack of more global experience is a liability in her mind.
“I’m not hearing people say I’m not looking at him because he’s gay,” said Malheiro, who is leaning toward supporting former Vice President Joe Biden or California Sen. Kamala Harris.