During Merkel’s last rodeo, would a pandemic rescue deal seal her legacy?
BRUSSELS» Finishing her 15th year as chancellor of Germany, Angela Merkel, the European Union’s longest-serving and most respected leader, now has her last, best chance to shape the future of the bloc and her own legacy.
With her long reign winding down, she and Germany have assumed the EU’S rotating presidency, which lasts through the end of the year, at a moment when the bloc is badly divided over a coronavirus recovery plan, a new seven-year budget and threats to the rule of law in eastern member states.
Merkel faced her first big test Friday, when she and other leaders convened their first in-person summit in Brussels since the coronavirus outbreak took hold in Europe five months ago. With a sense of urgency, they were trying to hash out a consensus on how best to help European nations clobbered by the virus.
EU leaders on Saturday extended their summit by an extra day, convinced they were closing in on a deal for an unprecedented $2.1 trillion EU budget and coronavirus recovery fund, an EU official said.
Expectations for Merkel’s leadership are high. But while this may be her last rodeo, many expect the same cautious pragmatism and reluctance to take bold, transformative steps that have characterized her time in office and her response to past European crises.
As a politician, Merkel, soon to be 66, remains, as ever, deliberately opaque, allowing many to imagine her support for their own preferred outcomes. But as much as she is committed to the European Union, she has consistently sought that sweet spot where German and European interests align, guided by German public opinion and her own careful personality.
While she has understood in the current crisis that the European economy needs a rescue, she is also keenly aware that Germany needs a strong European economy for its own continued prosperity.
That, as much as anything, led her to break new ground with France by backing pooled debt among EU members to stave off the economic crash of the pandemic — what she last week called “the greatest test the European Union has ever faced.”
The proposal — grants worth about $570 billion for regions hit hardest by the pandemic — represented a reversal of the fierce German opposition to collective European debt.
Some hailed her move as a sea change, one that would seal her legacy as a Europeanist, much as Helmut Kohl is remembered for his support of the euro currency.
But others are skeptical, instead seeing a unique and typically pragmatic response to a crisis that threatened the European single market and thus the German economy.
Merkel, who tends to say what she means, has made it clear that such largess was a “one-off.”
“Germany has moved a lot,” said Daniela Schwarzer, the director of the German Council on Foreign Relations in Berlin. “Germans were always ready in the presidency to put a bit more on the table, but without the virus, there would have been no revolution in the budget.”
Ulrich Speck, a senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund in
Berlin, said that Merkel remained true to herself, and that she was shifting only because Germans, deeply embedded in the European Union, want to help those ravaged by the pandemic, especially in Italy and Spain.
“For her, this does not really change the European Union, and public opinion is behind it,” Speck said. “This is not controversial; this is crisis management. What would be controversial would be a permanent change of structure.”
But others, especially European federalists in France and Italy, dare to believe Merkel harbors secret sympathy for deeper European integration and prefer to see her as breaking a taboo.
Even if that were true, with her time in office coming to an end, any more permanent shift in policy would have to come from her successor, and few believe that the current band of potential chancellors would have the political weight, let alone the desire, to repeat the exercise.
But first she must get a deal, which will not be simple, given that all 27 member countries must agree.