The best films for children: Observer readers have their say
There’s a special emotional bond with the films we discover as children that is somehow purer, more cherishable than anything we forge later in life. For me, a bedrock moment in my love of cinema was working my way through a box of VHS copies of 1930s musicals, mesmerised by the glittering repartee and the effortless elegance of old Hollywood. Even now, watching clips of Fred Astaire, Ginger Rogers and Eleanor Powell tap routines is a shortcut to a happy place. But, as shown by the response to Mark Kermode’s excellent and very personal list of 25 of the best films for children published here two weeks ago, everyone has their own treasured childhood movie touchstone.
The replies to the list include passionately argued cases for everything from Who Framed Roger Rabbit (which would definitely make my own roll call of best children’s films) and The Princess Bride (likewise) to the Roberto Benigni-starring holocaust drama Life Is Beautiful (not so much). But the point of Mark’s list, and the aspect that makes it such a rewarding read, was the decision to embrace the scope of family cinema at its broadest possible interpretation. As anyone with children under 10 will no doubt concur, much of the more recent content targeted at younger audiences represents a world of pain for older ones – just gaze into the hollow, haunted eyes of any adult who has had to endure The Emoji Movie.
Rather than churned out bargainbasement kids’ movies, the audience is far better served by films that emphasise the “family” in family entertainment – a collective, unifying experience to be shared and enjoyed by all ages. This might entail taking children out of their comfort zone a little, with subtitles or silent films; with the wrenchingly sad ending of Kes, for example or, to give a more recent example, the genuinely scary peril in Paddington, another film that was a popular choice with readers. Nicole Kidman as a renegade taxidermist lovingly stroking her glinting arsenal of scalpels while Paddington lies unconscious provides a shiveringly terrifying moment.
But as someone whose formative childhood movie experiences included a possibly unhealthy degree of tapdancing, I was particularly delighted to see the support for Singin’ inthe Rain in the readers’ responses. It’s a terrific suggestion, and one that goes to the top of my movie-night viewing list of film treasures to share with my eight-yearold. Wendy Ide
Bedknobs and Broomsticks (1971)
Blitz-era musical fantasy starring Angela Lansbury as a witchcraft-practising governess“That football scene will always be a delight. As well as the comedy, Bedknobs may have been the first time many children were introduced to war coming to our doorsteps and the real impact of the war on children not many generations before them.”stuckinazoo
The Princess Bride (1987)
William Goldman’s wry fairytale adventure, in which a farmhand must rescue a princess“The film that has everything: Fred Savage, Columbo, a giant, Billy Crystal, Robin Wright (grrrr), magic, sword fights. Has to be more engaging for kids than Kes, surely.” June Junes
Singin’ in the Rain (1952)
Effervescent classic musical with Gene Kelly and Debbie Reynolds as silent film stars struggling to make a talkie“I saw Singin’ in the Rain as a child in a cinema (in the early 70s, a rerelease), walked into the theatre as a six or seven year old, not having a clue of what I was about to see (other than it looked like a happy movie), and by the end credits I was in heaven. It is the one film that changed my life for the better and it has not a single sad moment in it. The film I treasure the most.”Nebelglanz
Watership Down (1978)
An animated tale of rabbits in peril, based on the unsettling 1972 novel by Richard Adams“[My] first cinema experience [which] possibly traumatised mum more than me. It’s an animation classic, a creation myth for rabbits, and, like the most popular fairy tales, kids can actually cope with the horror and being a bit scared.”
Annabel Houghton,
London south-west
Jason and the Argonauts (1963)
The legendary quest for the golden fleece, with pioneering stop-motion animation from Ray Harryhausen“I remember my grandparents showing me it in the early 90s, about 30 years after it had been released, and thinking it was the best thing ever. The special effects seemed like the most modern and advanced stuff possible, even though it was made in 1963.”BigCherryDingDong
The Iron Giant (1999)
A giant robot falls from outer space and befriends a young boy in this adaptation of a Ted Hughes story“I agree strongly [with the many other commenters who recommended it]. Fantastic film.”Dingfelder
The Muppet Christmas (1992)
Uproarious take on the Yuletide classic, with Kermit as Bob Cratchit, Gonzo as Charles Dickens and Michael Caine as Scrooge“The finest adaptation of Mr Dickens’s tale in existence.”Gordon, Manchester
Spirited Away (2001)
Highly imaginative Studio Ghibli animation featuring a lost girl, pigs, witches and a vomiting spirit“However old you are I urge you to watch this film and I guarantee you will take something from it.”Harry Dibbs
Life Is Beautiful (1997)
Roberto Benigni shields his son from the horrors of a Nazi concentration camp in this Oscar-winning comedy-drama“Would Life Is Beautiful be suitable for older kids? If so, it should definitely be on this list. An absolute masterpiece.”Matthew James, Barcelona
Fantastic Planet (1973)
French-Czech animation about a human uprising against alien overlords on a faraway planet“I saw it in the cinema when it first came out. It blew my young mind and still resonates after all of these years.”JSpicoli, North Wales
The Black Stallion (1979) Carol
A boy is shipwrecked with an Arabian horse in an American adaptation of the 1941 Walter Farley children’s classic“It’s a superb mysterious story, almost wordless for much of its time. It’s one of these rare films that doesn’t talk down to children but invites you into its mysterious and complete world. I think it works equally well for adults too.”Ewan Small, Giffnock, Glasgow
Mouse Hunt (1997)
Two brothers inheriting a dilapidated mansion are foiled by a diminutive foe in this fast-paced slapstick comedy“One film for the whole family, even the much older kids among you, which I can’t recommend highly enough. It features quite possibly the single most charismatic titular lead of any film.”asemblanceofchaos
Who Framed Roger Rabbit (1988)
Cartoon characters and live-action humans coexist unharmoniously in Robert Zemeckis’s comedy starring Bob Hoskins as a toon-hating detective“My favourite film as a kid (I still remember all of the words). Along with The Lion King, I’d say that it reinvigorated the animation field. It helped revive the idea that (part) animated films can be interesting for kids and adults, and weren’t just something to stick the kids in front of for 90 minutes while parents got on with something else.”
David Wall, Northampton
To Kill a Mockingbird (1962)
Much-loved adaptation of the Harper Lee novel, with Gregory Peck as Atticus Finch and Robert Duvall as Boo Radley“I remember watching it with my