Menstruation apps store excessive information, privacy charity says
Menstruation apps are unnecessarily storing personal data such as what medication women are on, their birth control habits and how hard women find it to reach orgasm, privacy campaigners have said.
A study of five leading apps by Privacy International, a UK-based charity, found that companies held intimate information on users including answers to questions about when they have yeast infections and how often they have sex or see a gynaecologist.
The use of menstruation apps has risen in recent years, with increasing numbers of women using them to record their cycle and to help them get pregnant.
Privacy international are arguing that registration should be optional on these apps, and should not require an email address. They want data to be stored on the phone, adding that only information strictly required to provide information related to the menstrual cycle should be collected.
It follows research from the charity last year that found that some apps have been sharing their users’ private information with Facebook.
Their latest research has been described by legal experts, a former minister and a period poverty charity as “very disturbing”.
Eva Blum-Dumontet, a senior researcher at Privacy International, who used five apps and then asked what information was held about her using a data subject access request, said reading the findings was “chilling” and “it makes us realise just how much data those apps actually collect, store and sometimes share with others.”
She added that it’s easy to think that data disappears into the ether when we are constantly asked to share more “and this is why requesting our data from the apps we use is a good exercise.”
Ravi Naik, legal director the data rights agency AWO, said the revelations were concerning, adding that transparency was vital for these apps.
The research found Flo, a period tracker and pregnancy app, keeps data on what users write in their “notes” section. They stored the answers to a range of questions including how hard it is for women to orgasm. Another section of the app lets users write what medication they are taking which is also accessible to the platform.
Flo shares data with a number of outside companies, which they say is to improve how the app works.
A spokesperson from Flo said: “As with nearly any app, Flo utilises thirdparty service providers to better understand the usage of its product so it can improve user experience and ensure the accuracy of the app’s insights which our users rely on. To be clear, Flo never sells user data or shares sensitive user data with third parties for advertising or any other use beyond helping improve the functionality of the app.”
Clue, an app produced by Biowink, had potential access to users’ birthdays, if the birth control section had been filled, and if Fitbit was enabled. Every time a user interacts with the app, the information is collected and stored and tied to a device ID and location. The company shares data with a number of external parties.
A Clue spokesperson said it has never sold or would sell data. They said they stored user data safely. It also helped fix bugs. They added that data helps them carry out research with academic universities and other organisations, noting that in that instance all datasets are de-identified before being shared.
A spokesperson for the Information Commissioner’s Office, UK’s data protection watchdog, said: “Under data protection law, organisations have to ensure that their processing is fair, lawful and transparent and that appropriate security is in place. In addition, special category data – such as health information – requires greater protection because of its sensitivity.”