Derry Girls review – this modern classic goes out on a high
All good things must come to an end – particularly if that good thing is a beloved British sitcom. Like myriad comedies before it, Lisa McGee’s semiautobiographical Derry Girls (Channel 4) – a knockabout schooldays farce set in mid-90s Northern Ireland – has opted to go out on a high with its third series. There’s a reason why UK shows tend to quit while they’re ahead: they often rely on a single creative force rather than a bustling US-style writers’ room, which means they are liable to exhaust their makers. On a less technical note, that the supposedly 16-year-old protagonists are currently being played by actors fast approaching 30 (one is 35) means Derry Girls has never been the most sustainable of enterprises.
Even so, it will be a bittersweet goodbye. Over the past four years, Derry Girls has established itself as a cultural juggernaut: not only is it the most-watched series in Northern Ireland on record, it was recently honoured with a reference in The Simpsons (“I. Am. dead,” tweeted McGee in response). Its success is no fluke: the show is a masterclass in hitting the sweet spot between decades-honed sitcom tradition and refreshing nowness. Its nostalgia is bright and cosy like a jazzy 90s jumper; its portrayal of young women as morally ambivalent and intrinsically comic human beings a cathartic, satisfying relief.
We rejoin the gang to discover that – in great sitcom tradition – little has changed. The girls remain their archetypal but not quite hackneyed selves:
Erin (Saoirse-Monica Jackson) is still a pretentious wannabe poet in the vein of Rick from The Young Ones (but with important global events to write about). Her cousin Orla (Louisa Clare Harland) is still the spaced-out eccentric; Nicola Coughlan’s Clare the neurotic and nerdy goody-two-shoes. Cocky party animal Michelle (JamieLee O’Donnell) is still by far the funniest character: not just because she gets all the greatest lines, but also because O’Donnell has markedly superior comic timing, which means she doesn’t have to ham it up quite as much as the rest of the cast. Token boy James (Dylan Llewellyn), meanwhile, is still … English.
The sense of place is as heady as ever, too. In the two episodes available to view in advance, the Troubles feature less prominently – partly because Ireland in this timeline is entering a period of relative peace. But McGee manages to preserve the tone that makes Derry Girls not only gratifyingly profane but also profound: conflict and terror may continually loom, but the finer points of teenage life always take precedent. In previous episodes, scenes that juxtapose the girls’ entirely selfabsorbed moments – dancing euphorically on a school hall stage, for example – with their parents anxiously watching the news, end up being far more than the sum of their parts. As the third series opens, the Troubles continue to be mostly an inconvenience, with Michelle snapping at the mere mention of politics: “I’m so fucking sick of peace!” she growls.
Luckily for Michelle, the plot that follows this outburst has nothing to do with the peace process. Or, indeed, anything even remotely noble or constructive. The gang are waiting for their GCSE results when they bump into Sister Michael, the sardonic headteacher of Our Lady Immaculate College (Siobhán McSweeney, imperiously understated as ever), who hints that the girls are in for a nasty surprise. Cue – obviously – a school break-in to intercept the offending grades, during which the group cluelessly abet some actual thieves. The climax involves an interview at the police station with Liam Neeson playing the frustrated detective in charge – a starry cameo that underlines the show’s heft, but also serves to temporarily burst the homely, wholly immersive bubble that is the Derry Girls universe.
That puncturing is all the more noticeable because of how important the stifling nature of the girls’ world is, fuelling the giddy hysteria that permeates practically every scene. Its source is partly school life – Derry Girls remains excellent at evoking the atmosphere of an all-girls’ school: claustrophobic, yes, but also an environment that allows for much unselfconscious joy. But the show’s real secret is the way it luxuriates in the low-stakes, lower middleclass domestic minutiae of Erin and Orla’s home life. Derry Girls has never neglected its adult characters – Erin’s mother, father, aunt (Orla’s mother) and grandfather – and the place where mundane household tasks intersect with the family’s intense gossiping style has provided some of the show’s most perfectly observed and distinctive storylines (the big bowl affair from series two is a sublime bit of comedy writing). Previous triumphs in this area mean the series three opener’s stray cat plot feels a bit thin (on the upside, it does prompt a great 90s choker joke), but later episodes ensure the grown-up dimension is as fleshed-out as ever.
Although this is nominally the end, McGee has hinted that she would like to make a Derry Girls movie – presumably keen to follow The Inbetweeners model (make three hugely popular series of a show, then rake it in with the highest-grossing British comedy film of all time). It doesn’t seem like a brilliant idea. If anything, Derry Girls’ return is a reminder that its airless setting, effusive acting and cosy kitchen-sink detailing combine into something approaching the platonic ideal of a TV sitcom. Derry Girls is that rare thing: a brand new classic, in the best possible sense.
Derry Girls season 3 is on Channel 4 in the UK. US and Australia releases have not yet been announced.
The climax involves an interview at the police station with Liam Neeson playing the frustrated detective in charge