Parents battle to recoup special education services lost to Covid
Marissa Sladek knew her son Christopher had fallen far behind when she bought him a copy of Jack London’s The Call of the Wild. The movie had opened just before the pandemic, and survival-themed fiction was his favorite.
The Covid lockdown had cut him off from the literacy support he had been receiving as a special education student. During remote learning sessions, his autism and learning disabilities left him unable to navigate email or video-communication applications. By the following year, when he entered the seventh grade, Christopher was reading near a third grade level.
“He could read the words”, his mother said, “but he couldn’t comprehend them.”
Sladek asked the Hillsborough Township school district in central New Jersey about compensatory education – the term for a district’s duty to make up services when it fails to provide them to students with disabilities. By Sladek’s calculation, her son had lost about 8,000 minutes of instruction. The district initially offered a fraction of that amount – 300 minutes – and according to her complaint, an official said they weren’t going to “dwell on the past”. An attorney for the district emailed to say officials don’t “believe that Christopher is entitled to any compensatory education”.
Parents around the country are facing similar pushback as they try to recoup services lost to the pandemic. It is the latest battle in one of the most litigated arenas in education. In a 2020 survey, just 20% of parents of students with disabilities said their children were receiving required services, and a 2021 report said the pandemic was exacerbating learning gaps for those students.
The frustration among parents is just one of the myriad ways school closures have cast a long shadow over the nation’s education system more than two years after the pandemic began. Recent national test scores show historic declines in reading and math achievement, and experts say it could be another three to five years before performance rebounds to pre-Covid levels.
While Congress allocated $122bn in recovery funds for schools over a year ago, districts are struggling to spend that money, plagued by staff shortages, especially in hard-to-fill positions, like special education.
To accommodate students with disabilities, some districts offered teletherapy, but most were unable to provide the same support students received in school. District officials say they can’t be blamed for a public health disaster that was out of their control. They insist teachers did the best they could under extraordinary circumstances.
“There is no humanly way possible to make up for 12 months, 13 months, 14 months of services if a school was shut down. It would take years,” said Phyllis Wolfram, executive director of the Council of Administrators of Special Education. “We have to think reasonably and logically.”
Federal officials see things differently and launched civil rights investigations in three districts and one state. Last month, the US Department of Education reached an agreement with the Fairfax county public schools in Virginia, requiring them to identify which students they failed to serve and begin to make up for it.
“I started shaking as I read the report, overwhelmed by happiness, sadness and anger,” said Callie Oettinger, a parent advocate who runs a website focusing primarily on special education in Fairfax county. “We could have avoided the destruction done to kids and to the relationships between educators and parents.”
But Wolfram said such requirements place undue burdens on school districts that are already spread thin. The debate is starting to play out in court. In Arkansas, a federal judge ruled in March that the Beebe school district doesn’t have to pay for a year of private school tuition for a student with dyslexia because teachers sent home packets of assignments and offered remote instruction.
A case from Washington DC went in the opposite direction. A judge ruled in March that the district owes a child compensatory services because federal law “contains no exception that would allow suspending special education services because a global pandemic forced schools online”.
‘You don’t get that time back’
Across the country, many parents didn’t hear from their children’s therapists or teachers for months after schools shut down.
“I have seen so much neglect and carelessness and the absolute marginalization of these kids during and after the pandemic,” said Georgianna JuncoKelman, a special education attorney who represents families in Los Angeles. “These kids are not going to regain those skills. You don’t get that time back.”
The LA district’s failure to main
tain services for students caught the attention of then education secretary Betsy DeVos in the final days of the Trump administration, sparking an investigation by the department’s office for civil rights.
The probe found that staff members counted simple emails and phone calls to families as actual services to students, and didn’t consider students’ individual needs.
Under an agreement superintendent Alberto Carvalho signed in April – similar to the one in Fairfax county – the district must determine how many of its 66,000 students with disabilities are now eligible for services.
Similar probes targeted the Seattle public schools and the Indiana department of education after federal officials received multiple complaints from parents in the state.
Some districts did scramble to find solutions. Just weeks after schools shut down in New Jersey’s Tinton Falls school district, about an hour southeast of Hillsborough, special education director Kerri Walsifer began reviewing the individualized education programs (IEPs) that guide the instruction of special education students to see what the district could realistically provide.
And when educators couldn’t come through, she tried to make it right.
Prior to the pandemic, Tinton Falls paid for Lina Esposito’s daughter Ella, who has attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and autism, to attend school in the nearby Long Branch district, which was better equipped to meet her needs. But when students returned from remote learning last fall, teachers complained about Ella’s behavior. They said she refused to go outside for a fire drill and was a “safety risk”, and that Long Branch was no longer a good fit for her.
But Walsifer didn’t have a spot for her in Tinton Falls either. That left Ella at home with no services until this past February, when the district found her a new school.
The special education director arranged for Ella to receive speech therapy and behavioral support to make up for some of the services she missed.
‘They tear you up’
But other families found districts unwilling to negotiate. For Los Angeles parents Lori and Stephen Saux, the request for compensatory education turned into a drawn-out struggle that ended with them pulling their son Liam out of the district.
“They tear you up, and they make you feel helpless,” Lori said.
During remote learning sessions, Liam, who has Down syndrome, didn’t receive most of the services spelled out in his IEP, such as a modified physical education program and a resource teacher to help him practice challenging words before answering questions aloud in class.
To fill that void, his mother or father sat with him during video-conference sessions. The teachers would “joke and say, ‘You should get your teaching credential because you’re so good,’” Lori said. She didn’t find it funny.
Last fall, when Covid cases among students spiked, Liam’s doctor put him at a higher risk of infection and strongly advised against him returning to school in person until he was fully vaccinated. But school was the only place Liam could get the education he needed.
The conundrum didn’t end there. The district’s home hospital program turned Liam down because he wasn’t sick, and his IEP said placing him in the remote, independent study program would be inappropriate.
Home for four months with no education, he eventually enrolled in a charter school.
A spokesperson for the district said “student matters are confidential” and wouldn’t discuss the case.
Now at the Citizens of the World charter school, Liam remains uncomfortable in social situations after nearly two years without classmates and behavioral support, Lori said. It took him a while to sit with others at lunch and join in games. And he still struggles to construct a paragraph and “get out what he’s trying to say”.
His parents started a podcast to help others advocate for their children and go into negotiations with districts knowing what to expect.
“I don’t think their goal is to correct things,” she said. “I think their goal is to create a system that looks like they’re doing what they’re supposed to do.”