Outrage and calls for inquiry into Seattle officer who joked about crash victim
Outrage grew on Friday over a Seattle police officer’s remark that the life of a young woman killed by a speeding patrol car had “limited value”. Diplomats from India are asking for an investigation following the death of the Indian graduate student, as people in Seattle protested against the officer’s callous jokes caught on body-camera video.
The footage released this week contains audio of Officer Daniel Auderer, vice-president of the Seattle police officers guild, joking with the rankand-file police union’s president after a different officer’s speeding police car slammed into Jaahnavi Kandula at a crosswalk on 23 January.
Protesters on Thursday evening gathered at the Seattle intersection where the 23-year-old graduate student was fatally struck. The King countyprosecuting attorney’s office is conducting a criminal review of the crash.
Kevin Dave, the officer who struck Kandula, had been driving at 74mph (119km/h) in a 25mph (40km/h) zone on the way to an overdose call. Auderer responded to the crash to evaluate whether Dave had been impaired, the Seattle Times reported.
Later, Auderer left his body camera on as he called Mike Solan, the president of the Seattle police officers guild, to report what happened. In a recording released by the police department on Monday, Auderer laughs and suggests
Kandula’s life had “limited value” and the city should just write a check for $11,000.
At the demonstration on Thursday, five-year-old Layla Allibhai sat atop father Mo Allibhai’s shoulders while holding a sign saying: “I have unlimited value. So did Jaahnavi.”
Other protesters carried signs saying “Jail killer cops” and “Convict Kevin Dave”.
“I think this has galvanized people because it’s so blatant and disrespectful to put a value on a human’s life at $11,000,” Patricia Hunter, a co-chair of the community police commission, said on Friday. “And it galvanizes people to see that the culture at Seattle police department has some issues that need to be immediately addressed.”
Hunter’s commission was formed to hold police accountable, along with the office of the inspector general and the office of police accountability. Hunter said its next step was to work with those partners to see what charges might be brought in the case, what policies might have been broken and “to amplify the voices of the community which are enraged over this video, so that justice can be done”.
Manka Dhingra, the deputy majority leader in the Washington state senate, called Auderer’s comments “revolting”, the Seattle Times reported. The incidents are “precisely why there is a lack of trust between the community and law enforcement”, she said in a statement.
“We need partners in law enforcement, not adversaries. We need guardians, not warriors,” Dhingra wrote.
The consulate general of India in San Francisco tweeted that it had taken the “deeply troubling” matter up with authorities in Seattle and in Washington DC and that it wanted a thorough investigation and action against those involved. Newspapers in India have been following the case.
In a statement on Friday, the US state department called the situation disturbing.
“We are aware of, and are disturbed by, what was said about Ms Kandula’s death in the bodycam footage recently released by the Seattle police department,” the department said. “We would like to take this opportunity to express our sincere condolence to Ms. Kandula’s family and loved ones.”
The Seattle police officers’ guild said in a statement on Friday that it understood the outrage caused by the “highly insensitive comments”, but that the comments were taken out of context.
“Without context, this audio is horrifying and has no place in a civil society. It sullies the profession of law enforcement, the reputation of all Seattle police officers and paints Seattle in a terrible light,” the union said. “We feel deep sorrow and grief for the family of Jaahnavi Kandula as this video has revictimized them in an already tragic situation as they continue to mourn her death. We are truly sorry.”
But, the union said, “there is much more detail and nuance that has not been made public yet”.
Solan, who had been on the other end of the call with Auderer, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Friday.
Auderer, in an 8 August statement he provided to the office of police accountability that the union released on Friday, said Solan had lamented the death and that his own comments were intended to mimic how the city’s attorneys might try to minimize liability for it.
“I laughed at the ridiculousness of how these incidents are litigated and the ridiculousness of how I watched these incidents play out as two parties bargain over a tragedy,” Auderer wrote. “I understand that without context the comment could be interpreted as horrifying and crude.”
He denied that his remarks were “made with malice or a hard heart”.
Kandula was from Andhra Pradesh, a state in India’s southern coastal region. Relatives told the Seattle Times that Kandula came to Seattle so she could one day support her mother back home in India. Kandula was on track to receive a master’s in information systems this December from the Seattle campus of Northeastern University.