U.S. alliance with Turkey is valuable but also untenable
There are about 5,000 members of the U.S. military, mostly airmen, stationed at the huge, strategically located air base in Incirlik, Turkey, northwest of the Syrian border.
The American forces at Incirlik are also the custodians of about 50 B61 nuclear bombs. Data on these weapons is classified, but at their maximum yield each is 10 times more powerful than the bomb dropped on Hiroshima, according to Stars and Stripes.
It’s a “Dr. Strangelove” scenario: No one quite knows how the American contingent can secretly remove the deadly nukes from their concrete vaults, bring them out to the tarmac, load them on planes and fly them out safely over Turkish objections.
Turkey in the past has threatened to go nuclear itself should the U.S. ever dare to transfer the lethal arsenal. Apparently, Turkey’s theory is that possession of bombs in one’s territory is 9/10ths of the law of nuclear weapons ownership.
In the aftermath of the Turkish invasion of Cyprus in 1974, which led to a U.S. arms embargo, Turkey shut down all U.S. operations at Incirlik. American forces were expelled for three years — until Washington caved and resumed arms supplies.
In 2016, Turkey cut off power to the base and forbid U.S. flights, fearing dissident Turkish generals of a failed coup attempt might use the American facility as a sanctuary
Under Islamist strongman Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Turkey has become NATO’s only nondemocratic nation. It’s also NATO’s only Muslim-majority member. Erdogan has been trying to re- create Turkey as a new Ottoman imperial power. He feels no allegiance to Western-style democracy.
During the Obama administration, Erdogan snubbed the obsequious American attempts to promote Turkey as the cornerstone of America’s Middle East policy. President Trump should remember that and perhaps reconsider his own sometimes appeasing outreach to Erdogan.
Turkey opposes, if not detests, almost every American ally in the region, and befriends almost every U.S. enemy.
It despises Israel, and aids its enemies. Turkey is currently attacking the U.S.-allied Kurds in Syria. It works against the proAmerican Sisi regime in Egypt.
The European Union has limited arms sales to Turkey. Germany has pulled its small forces out of the country. Recently, Turkish forces “accidentally” shelled a U.S. Special Forces peacekeeping outpost on the Turkish-Syrian border.
Why, then, is the U.S. still an ally of this anti-American rogue nation? There are a number of scary reasons.
The U.S. military hasn’t figured out how to stay in or leave Incirlik in a now-hostile Turkey. Fighters at Incirlik can reach any strategic conflict in the Middle East.
American diplomats naively hope that democracy will return to Turkey and that Erdogan is a temporary nuisance. America fears that a hostile Turkey could start and win wars against our vulnerable regional friends and create a formidable nuclear alliance with Russia, China or Iran.
NATO in general is underfunded and undermanned. In contrast, NATO member Turkey has the second-largest military in the alliance at nearly 650,000 troops. Europe and the U.S. either believe such a force helps maintain credible NATO deterrence or are terrified it will be put into the service of others.
The U.S. fears that fighting against, or failing to aid, a NATO partner might unravel the entire alliance. Turkey has invoked Article IV of the treaty, requiring crisis consultation when a NATO ally claims it is threatened, three times in its regional disputes.
Not since the U.S. came to the aid of Josef Stalin’s USSR in World War II has America so disliked and so feared a valuable but utterly untenable ally.