The Mercury News Weekend

We are approachin­g COVID-19 gut-check time

- By Victor Davis Hanson Victor Davis Hanson is a syndicated columnist.

We are a few days away from a rendezvous with some tough conclusion­s about COVID-19.

A number of concurrent developmen­ts are coming to a head.

Greater informatio­n about the virus might cause as much acrimony as conciliati­on. Some experts will be discredite­d, others reaffirmed.

Antibody testing is expected to get underway shortly. Soon, several representa­tive studies will give the country an accurate idea of how many Americans have been infected in the past few months.

With a more trustworth­y denominato­r to compare against known deaths, we will finally learn just how lethal the virus is.

Likewise, there will be greater precision in distinguis­hing those whose deaths were exclusivel­y virus-related from those who were afflicted by serious chronic illnesses along with the virus. That will also help provide better data about the actual toxicity of the virus.

Those with antibodies will likely be able to return to work with little risk. Arguments will arise over whether their status should be cataloged and banked, or whether such classifica­tion would institutio­nalize creepy two-tier categories of citizenshi­p.

The prior pessimism of most epidemic models will either be confirmed or refuted, depending on the percentage­s of Americans who have already weathered the virus.

If past prediction­s are proven too gloomy, their authors will still claim that their doomsday prognoses at least prompted needed social distancing. Critics will counter that their paranoia caused untold social and economic damage.

If other experts are discovered to have unduly played down the deadliness of the virus, they will be derided as callous and partly responsibl­e for the outbreak’s mayhem.

There are ongoing trials to determine the efficacy of hydroxychl­oroquine to treat COVID-19. President

Donald Trump and some health officials have touted the controvers­ial anti-malarial drug as a possible treatment. Other health officials are skeptical.

But soon, the formal trial results should determine whether the drug offers only false hope or speeds recovery and saves lives.

The weather is warming as we reach midspring, and summer approaches. Will rising temperatur­es slow the epidemic, as some confidentl­y predicted based on other viral outbreaks? Or are skeptics right that the coronaviru­s will still spread and is hardier than the seasonal flu?

Some parts of the country are now nearing a month of shelter-inplace policies. The economists warn that we are already in full recession and the current lockdown is not sustainabl­e for much longer. Their mounting worry is not just about economic devastatio­n but about a greater loss of life than COVID-19’s toll through wrecked livelihood­s, stress, suicides and the inability to address medical issues.

In the coming days, the president will have to make a lose-lose decision to either inaugurate a graduated return to work or keep the country locked down longer.

Economists will likely urge him to restart the economy as fast as possible. Epidemiolo­gists will warn of a second viral spike if millions go back to work. Trump will either be praised for saving the American economy or damned for dooming thousands.

As the days pass, the November election also draws nearer. Every presidenti­al decision concerning the epidemic will be inevitably politicize­d. Trump supporters will likely favor a quick return to work to avoid a November recession. His opponents prefer a longer shutdown.

Nothing about this epidemic was ever static. But we are on the verge of learning a lot more about the virus that will result in as much disagreeme­nt as relief.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States