Will Indo-American vote ‘fall in line’ for Khanna?
When it comes to politics, community is rarely cohesive, with roots in a country where democracy is at its ‘messiest’
Indian-Americans have a saying about themselves that should make Ro Khanna a little nervous as he tries for a second time to unseat San Jose Congressman Mike Honda: “Two Indians, three opinions.” Khanna, the U.S.-born son of Indian immigrants, is counting on the Indian-American community to come out in force on Nov. 8 to help catapult him into Congress to represent a swath of Silicon Valley stretching from Fremont to Cupertino. But when it comes to politics, Indian-Americans have been far more successful at bankrolling candidates of Indian heritage than galvanizing behind them.
As Khanna learned from his narrow loss two years ago, it’s hard to weave together a cohesive voting bloc out of a constituency whose members trace their roots back to a country with 22 official languages and
nine major religions. That task is even more difficult as a challenger running against Honda, a JapaneseAmerican who attended high school in San Jose, has been elected to four different offices, and has had decades to build relationships with Indian-Americans of all stripes.
“It would be presumptuous for anyone to think they can get such a diverse community to rally completely around them,” said Khanna, 40, whose campaign is suddenly fighting allegations from Honda that his former campaign manager, Brian Parvizshahi, had illegally accessed Honda campaign files. Khanna, who accepted Parvizshahi’s resignation Thursday, called Honda’s lawsuit containing the allegations “baseless,” maintaining it was a way to divert attention from the House’s ethics investigation of Honda.
Political power
Members of the IndianAmerican community have had enormous success launching Silicon Valley startups and now run gold standard companies like Google and Adobe, but Indian-Americans are largely absent from the corridors of political power — even in the 17th congressional district, where they account for 1 in 10 voters.
The numbers are particularly grim in Khanna’s adopted hometown of Fremont. Indian- and ChineseAmerican residents each make up about 20 percent of the city’s 224,000 residents. Yet there are two Chinese-American City Council members and one school board member — and none of Indian heritage.
“In Silicon Valley, there is a sense among Chinese-Americans that Indo-Americans are doing better when it comes to business leadership and rising up quickly to positions of corporate power,” said Karthick Ramakrishnan, a UC Riverside political science professor who directs the National Asian American Survey. When it comes to politics, though, Indians Democratic challenger Ro Khanna, left, and Rep. Mike Honda, D-San Jose, shake hands after a 2014 debate. marvel at the success of their Chinese-American neighbors.
“It’s sad that we haven’t achieved the same success in politics as we have in other endeavors,” said Raj Salwan, a veterinarian and Democratic Party donor who is trying for the second time to win election to the Fremont City Council.
Indo-Americans point to several factors for their lack of political power: They are recent immigrants with relatively low voter-turnout rates.
And, like Khanna, they are more likely to start off seeking higher office instead of building a pipeline of local candidates through local city council and school boards. But perhaps the biggest impediment, they say, is the no-holds-barred political culture of India, where conflict is embraced and cohesion is hard to muster.
“It’s democracy at its best and messiest,” said former Fremont Councilwoman Anu Natarajan, who ran unsuccessfully for mayor four years ago. Or as Salwan, who campaigned for Natarajan’s white opponent in that mayor’s race, put it: “We don’t fall into line, so to speak.”
And they say that puts them at a disadvantage against the more established and cohesive Chinese-American community, whose members have built extensive political networks to help elect candidates.
Ignatius Ding, a Chinese-American community leader in Cupertino, said the greater cohesion among Chinese immigrants is partly cultural and partly a response to racism they faced when immigrating to the country. “There was a concerted effort to organize Chinese-Americans for self-preservation,” he said. “Indo-Americans didn’t face the same kind of challenge, so they behave differently.”
Khanna, who said his favorite book is “The Argumentative Indian” by Nobel Prize-winning Indian economist Amartya Sen, has been working for nearly a decade to paper over divisions and offer himself as a unifying force in his community.
He stresses his grandfather’s participation in the struggle for Indian independence, while presenting himself as a second-generation secular Hindu who has moved beyond the divisions of the old country.
Khanna also has reached out to Sikhs, a minority religious group in India that still nurses wounds of state-sanctioned violence against them — most notably in 1984, when thousands of Sikhs were killed after a Sikh man assassinated Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, a Hindu.
Appearing with Honda at the Fremont Sikh temple two years ago, Khanna called the mass killings “a genocide,” a position not held by the U.S. State Department. When pressed by his hosts, Honda wouldn’t use the term “genocide.”
“That is what made me support Ro,” said Amrit Sra, a Silicon Valley executive who attended the event.
‘A friend’
Honda’s Sikh supporters note that he was a staunch advocate for them after 9/11 when Sikh men, who wear beards and turbans, were attacked by people who thought they were Muslim. “A lot of us consider him a friend,” said Sarabjit Cheema, a school board member from Union City and former temple official.
Ishan Shah, a 24-yearold Indian-American who sits on the Ohlone College Board of Trustees, said his mother calls him “Little Ro” because of his political ambitions. But he is also close to Honda, who Shah said always made time for him at Democratic Party events, even when he was still in high school.
Indian-American leaders say they sense stronger support for Khanna this time around, and last June’s primary election results seem to support their case. After losing to Honda by 20 percentage points in the 2014 primary, Khanna won this year’s contest by 2 percentage points, running strongest in heavily Indian-American precincts in South Fremont and Cupertino.
“I think the community will converge around Ro,” said Saratoga Councilman Rishi Kumar. “And he might become the big uniter who can work across political and religious lines and help us collaborate for the common good.” the yearslong run-up has put the squeeze on typical income earners, who easily can spend half of their pretax wages on rent.
“While incomes have gone up dramatically, rents also have gone up to the point where we’ve reached an equilibrium,” said Jeffrey M. Mishkin, regional manager at the San Francisco office of Marcus & Millichap, a real estate brokerage firm. For much of the region, rents “either can’t or don’t need to go up anymore.”
From August 2015 to August 2016, he said, San Francisco’s rental market “was flat.”
“One-bedrooms were down 7.7 percent year-overyear, from $3,395 to $3,150. Two-bedrooms were down from $4,500 to $4,300, a 4.7 percent drop.”
Plus, he just had received an informal report about a “very large owner” of apartments on the Peninsula “who said that rents are down on every one of his properties.”
Think small
And, yes, Oakland rents have continued to rise as the city attracts young professionals looking for some affordability and easy access to jobs across the bay. Even so, Mishkin said, East Bay brokers sense a slowdown: “The smaller units are renting quickly. The larger, more expensive units are taking longer.”
Stern advised apartment hunters to look in smaller apartment developments, rather than the larger — and often more expensive — complexes.
“You can get a nice place for $1,600 or $1,700, maybe less,” he said. “There’s a nice duplex in Campbell for $1,850 in a good neighborhood. The landlord says, ‘I don’t want to squeeze it for an extra 200 bucks. I just want to get it rented.’ ”
“Landlords beware,” he warned. “People are shopping price, not quality, right now.”
If so, Abodo’s future reports could show continuing declines. It based its September findings for San Jose, San Francisco and Oakland on a sampling of 6,701 properties, according to Sam Radbil, the website’s spokesperson.