The Mercury News

Does the United States still have that place called ‘us’?

- By Leonard Pitts Jr. Miami Herald Leonard Pitts Jr. is a Miami Herald columnist. © 2020, Miami Herald. Distribute­d by Tribune Content Agency.

Saturday night, I ordered takeout from my favorite Chinese place. I did this as a gesture of solidarity after hearing that people were avoiding Chinese restaurant­s because of the coronaviru­s pandemic that originated in Wuhan, China.

I also did it because I craved egg foo young.

If my intended message was muddled by those mixed motivation­s, well, chalk it up to the fact that the pandemic has been hell on easy symbolism. This is supposed to be one of those times when Americans come together, when we put aside our singular, selfish needs and concentrat­e instead on acting in the best interests of the greater and larger us.

But you have to wonder just how you go about doing that. Or how you go about showing your fellow citizens you’re doing that.

Previous national crises lent themselves easily to symbolic gestures of solidarity and unity. After the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor, you joined the Marines, planted a Victory Garden or collected scrap metal. After John Kennedy was assassinat­ed, you wept in the streets end embraced strangers as kin. After the 2001 terrorist attacks, you gave blood and hung American flags from freeway overpasses.

But the pandemic of 2020 offers no equivalent symbolism of national unity. Instead, we hoard toilet paper and Purell, and get our egg foo young to go. It’s not quite the same.

Granted, that’s a stylistic issue, interestin­g but arguably inconseque­ntial. Except that it masks something larger. After all, if, in years past, we put aside our singular, selfish needs and sought what was right for the greater and larger us, these last years of unrelieved rancor, of Americans living in alternate political realities, requires an honest observer to wonder if those things are even still possible.

And I’m sorry, but you’ll read no false equivalenc­e here — not even in the service of hoped-for reconcilia­tion. Because the truth matters. And the truth is, it was the political right that seceded from that greater and larger “us,” that inculcated in its adherents a sense of separatene­ss, that made of them an island warmed by a burn of permanent grievance.

Nor has that stopped in the face of pandemic. Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity have suggested the disease isn’t all that serious. Rep. Devin Nunes and former Milwaukee Sheriff David Clarke have said, in defiance of all medical advice, that people should go out and do the town. Trish Regan, a since-suspended Fox Business anchor, claimed the “liberal media” were using the coronaviru­s to “destroy the president.”

Even during a pandemic, it seems, some of us find it hard to get beyond competing political agendas, hard to be one nation, indivisibl­e. On Dec. 7, 1941, Nov. 22, 1963, or even Sept. 11, 2001, that would have been impossible to conceive.

Yet, here we are.

Always previously, one thing has been reliably true of this fractious nation: In time of crisis, we come together. Now we’re about to learn if that’s still the case. The early returns aren’t good.

Make no mistake: As our health care system, supply chain and economy are being tested, we the people are also being tested in our very understand­ing of American identity. We are a balkanized nation, a collection of broken pieces where even the specter of mass casualties is just another excuse for political gamesmansh­ip. This moment forces upon us a defining question: Are we still capable of common cause?

Is there still a place called “us”?

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States