The Norwalk Hour

Family’s callous words hurt reader

- Amy Dickinson Ask Amy, P.O. Box 194, Freeville, NY 13068. e-mail: askamy@tribune.com

Dear Amy: I have struggled with my mental health my entire life.

I’ve been in and out of several psychiatri­c hospitals over the past few years.

I’ve always been private with my emotions, having been raised in a family that doesn’t talk about feelings. Therefore, my first hospital admission came as a surprise to my parents, though they did visit me often while I was there.

To this day, we still don’t talk about my struggles, nor have my parents asked me directly about why I was there.

I was recently at a (small, distanced) family gathering with my parents and an aunt.

Somehow, the conversati­on turned to my grandfathe­r’s service in WWII.

In what was framed as a funny anecdote, my parents and aunt repeatedly talked about my grandfathe­r’s time guarding the “loony bin.”

I was very taken aback by this phrase and the laughter that accompanie­d it. I was too surprised to react in the moment.

Several weeks later, I’m still supremely hurt by this conversati­on.

The derogatory comments toward the people in the hospital felt like a dagger to my heart.

I don’t know where to go from here. I haven’t had any contact with any of them since that day.

I’m No “Loony”

Dear No “Loony”: When people make a deeply insensitiv­e remark — or a slur — the appropriat­e response is to react honestly to it.

If you are able, reach out and tell them something along these lines: “I had never heard those stories from Grandpa’s service in WWII before.

Honestly, though, calling a hospital a ‘loony bin’ is a terrible thing to say. I was shocked when I heard people using that term. People who have mental illness are not ‘loony’, and they don’t spend time in a ‘bin,’ any more than people who have cancer do. I feel it is important to let you know that.”

My suggested script does not refer to your own experience in hospitals, which I sense hews to your family’s style.

Being more open about your own illness could be a gamechange­r for you. I hope you will talk to your therapist about ways to connect more deeply with your family. Your advocacy is a positive step in that direction.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States