YOUR VIEWS A bad execution plan

The latest bad idea emanating from the state Capitol is one to euthanize prisoners by nitrogen-induced suffocation. In this plan, an inmate would be placed in a gas chamber or have a mask placed over his head releasing nitrogen gas into his face. Nitrogen, an inert gas, replaces oxygen and slowly asphyxiates the person to death. The American Veterinary Medical Association has determined this method of euthanasia is unacceptable for dogs or cats. What makes state leaders think this could be acceptable for human beings?

This is how inhumane euthanasia by inert gas is for animals. To quote the AVMA, “Any gas that is inhaled must reach a certain concentration in the alveoli (lungs) before it can be effective; therefore, euthanasia with any of these agents takes some time.” In addition, the AVMA says of the nitrogen euthanasia process that “exposure times of greater than 7 minutes are needed to ensure killing of pigs.” We know pigs aren’t humans, but many aspects of their physiology are similar so it’s not a far stretch to think humans might respond in a similar fashion.

Veterinarians consider this method of euthanasia inhumane in mammals. It won’t be any different for human beings. To consider this idea, let alone publicly announce its consideration, reflects the depth of the lack of humaneness prevalent in state government.

Joe Carter, Norman

Carter is a veterinarian.