Big city homicide toll fell slightly in 2017

Dip in early data review follows two rough years

While New York and others boasted of significant progress, other large cities saw a big surge in killings.

The collective homicide toll for America’s 50 biggest cities dipped slightly in 2017, a USA TODAY analysis of crime data found.

The FBI won’t publish its annual comprehensive crime report until later this year, but an early review of police department crime data shows that killings decreased by at least 1% in large jurisdictions compared with 2016.

The modest decrease in killings comes after FBI data showed back-toback years in which homicides rose sharply in large cities. (Homicides in cities with 250,000 or more residents rose by about 15.2% from 2014 to 2015 and 8.2% from 2015 to 2016.)

There were 5,738 homicides in the nation’s 50 biggest cities in 2017 compared with 5,863 homicides in 2016, a roughly 2.3% reduction.

Las Vegas Police reported 141 homicides for 2017 in the city’s official tally but did not include the Oct. 1 mass shooting at an outdoor country music concert that left 58 dead. If those deaths were included in the department's tally, the national big city homicide toll would have fallen by just 1.1%, the USA TODAY review found.

Even with the sharp rise in homicides in the two years prior to 2017, the national murder toll continued to hover near historic lows.

The national decrease in killings in 2017 was largely driven by double-digit percentage dips in some of the nation’s biggest cities, including Chicago (14.7%), New York City (13.4%) and Houston (11%). In fact, the New York Police Department reported that its annual murder tally fell below 300 for the first time, and the city notched its lowest per capita murder rate in nearly 70 years.

New York, which hit its nadir in the midst of the crack cocaine epidemic when it tallied more than 2,200 murders in 1990, boasts that the nation’s largest city is now the safest it’s been since the Dodgers played in Brooklyn and a pizza slice set you back 15 cents.

While New York and others boasted of significant progress, other large cities saw a big surge in killings in 2017.

Columbus tallied 143 murders — 37 more than 2016 and the most the city has seen in a single year. Baltimore tallied 343 murders and ended 2017 with the highest per capita murder rate in the city’s history. In both cities, officials blamed the rise in homicides on gangs and drug activity.

“In New York, they concentrated on the right neighborhoods; they’ve invested well in predictive analytics and technology,” said Peter Scharf, a criminologist at the LSU School of Public Health and Justice. “The other part of what we’re seeing nationally might be a story of haves and have-nots. While some departments have made the investments, other police departments are still in the backwater of policing.”

Chicago saw its murder tally dip to 650 in 2017 from 762 in the prior year. The murder toll remains high in the Windy City — near levels of violence the city endured in the late 1990s — but police officials there say they believe investments in technology are beginning to help officers stem the violence.

Chicago is one of many big departments that has seen its relationship strained in poor and minority communities in the aftermath of a series of controversial police-involved shootings across the country in recent years.

Some crime experts and law enforcement officials believe the fractured relationships could have had some impact on driving homicide rates in recent years.