USA TODAY International Edition
Inequities roil access to paid leave
People of color facing hurdles, report says
When her husband became ill nearly two decades ago, Tameka Henry often had to take off a week or more every month to care for him and their children. That meant losing hundreds of dollars in income needed to buy groceries and pay bills because her jobs caring for people with disabilities didn’t offer paid leave.
In December, when she and her daughter contracted COVID- 19, Henry once again had to go without pay as she recuperated at home. Now, though she is still dealing with the fatigue and other lingering effects of the virus, Henry goes to work anyway.
“I needed it before the pandemic,” Henry, 43, says about the ability to take time off with pay. “Now that it’s a pandemic, it’s even more clear we really need it. ... It’s tough having to choose between your life and your livelihood.”
People of color, who are more likely to die and lose their jobs during the pandemic, also are less likely to have access to paid leave. That benefit would enable them to take time off to care for themselves and their families during the pandemic, a new report found.
Among workers, 50% of Latinos and 37% of African Americans say their employers did not offer time off with pay, compared with 34% of white employees, according to the report from the National Partnership for Women & Families, citing pre- pandemic data from the U. S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
“Women and people of color are forced to make the impossible choice between caring for themselves or a loved one, or a paycheck,” says Erika Moritsugu, vice president of government relations and economic justice for the NPWF.
Clara Vasquez says that in her last job as a home health aide, she would cobble together hours a month at a time to take care of her and her family’s needs.
By the end of the year, if she never took a day off, she’d have about a week of personal time – nowhere near enough to care for and supervise her 7year- old son when his school was shuttered because of the coronavirus crisis.
She recently took a new position at a pre- school in Granger, Washington, that gives her the paid leave she needs to deal with the unique challenges sparked by the health crisis.
“I could be with my family,” Vasquez
says, “and still get some money to pay bills and buy groceries.”
No national paid leave
The U. S. is one of the few nations in the world to not have a national paid leave policy. With the decision to provide that benefit largely left to employers, nearly 80% of private- sector workers do not have paid family leave through their jobs to care for a new child or other loved one.
The consequences of that gap are more critical for Black, Latino, Asian and Indigenous workers, who tend to earn lower wages and experience higher rates of unemployment as well as to be out of work for longer periods of time.
“The workers who are paid the least and have the least savings and ... other assets to fall back on are often the same workers in these jobs where employers aren’t stepping up to provide basic benefits like paid leave,” says Jessica Mason, senior policy analyst with the NPWF and one of the report’s authors.
During the COVID- 19 pandemic, women of color have disproportionately worked in jobs that put them at risk of contracting the virus.
“At the same time, they are more likely to have caregiving needs at home,” Mason says. That “places those women in the incredibly difficult position of deciding whether to be there for the family ... or at the job that puts food on the table.”
A survey cited in the report that was
taken from September to October and co- sponsored by the National Employment Law Project, found that 28% of Latinas had taken days off without pay or quit a job to take care of a child or elderly relative. That was compared with 27% of Black women, 12% of white women and 12% of men.
“We’ve seen much higher rates of housing insecurity with people unable to make rent or mortgage payments, and food insecurity,” Mason says. “All of those hardships are falling much more heavily on communities of color.”
Even when employers do have paid leave policies, the decision to grant time off often varies according to who is asking for it, the report found. Among Black employees who participated in the survey taken last fall, nearly 3 in 10 said their requests have been turned down, compared with 9% of white workers.
“Their employer can prevent them from taking it, or retaliate,” Mason says. “In the middle of a pandemic … those are disparities putting the health and wellbeing of workers of color at risk.”
Shutting out people of color
The Federal Family and Medical Leave Act offers job protection to workers who take unpaid leave. But it applies to only roughly 50% of workers, and its rigid guidelines often leave out many employees of color, according to the NPWF.
For instance, the law applies only to workplaces with at least 50 employees, and workers must have been on the payroll for at least a year and have worked at least 1,250 hours to qualify.
Women in general, women of color, and Black and Latino men are more like
ly to be given part- time shifts even if they ask for full- time hours, according to the report. And it’s particularly hard for Black and Latino workers to have longevity on the job when they tend to be laid off first during recessions and have more difficulty finding work because of bias, the NPWF says.
“When you take all of those things together, it disproportionately excludes Latinx, Asian American and Native American and Black workers,” Mason says. Latinx is a gender- neutral term preferred by some Hispanics.
Native American, Pacific Islander and multiracial employees are 100% more likely than their white peers to be unable to take time off when they need to, according to the NPWF report. Black employees are 83% more likely and Latino workers are 66% more likely than whites to face the same dilemma.
The primary reason is that they cannot afford to take time off without pay. Fear of being fired is also a key concern, the report’s researchers say.
Lost pay and jobs
Henry, who lives in Las Vegas, says she lost a series of jobs when employers grew frustrated with her needing to take off to care for her family. And the wages she lost when she had to stay home sometimes meant trips to food pantries and making special payment arrangements to handle bills.
In her current job working for a small nonprofit, Henry says she has an understanding boss and she doesn’t worry about losing her job. But Henry still doesn’t have paid leave. She lost roughly a month’s worth of wages when she and her daughter caught COVID- 19.
She’s already used up all the sick days she had for this year as she copes with COVID- 19’ s side effects.
“There are some days where I’ll make it here to work and ... you are just so fatigued,” Henry says. “But you have to sit here and try to make it through because you need to be able to take care of your family.”
Road to paid leave
Nine states and Washington D. C., have passed bills providing paid family and medical leave, and several more states have pending legislation, but a national policy would be the best way to help erase inequities, advocates say.
“We’re all sitting on top of ... a history of slavery, of inequitable immigration patterns, of colonization,” Mason says. “All these things over time have shaped our labor market in really important ways ... Leaving it up to individual employers to try to right those historical wrongs and somehow individually cobble together this critical safety net for employees has never worked, and it’s especially not working now.’’
Statewide policies have provided a national model. This year, nearly 200 members of Congress introduced The Family Act, a bill co- sponsored by Rep. Rosa DeLauro, D- Conn., and Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D- N. Y., that would create a national paid family and medical leave program, Moritsugu says.
It’s a policy Vasquez hopes to see. “We are all essential workers no matter what job we do,” she says. “And this will help all the families in the country who are struggling ( so they) do not have to decide whether to go to work or to choose family.’’