USA TODAY US Edition

Opposing view: The flawed Iran nuclear deal deserves to die

- Reuel Marc Gerecht Reuel Marc Gerecht, a former CIA officer, is a senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracie­s.

President Trump’s decision to withdraw the U.S. from the Iran nuclear deal should be viewed as condign punishment for the disingenuo­us way Barack Obama and his staff sold the agreement to the American public.

The deal does not “cut off every pathway that Iran could take to develop a nuclear weapon.” Once the regime perfects advanced centrifuge­s, which is allowed under the accord, the Islamic Republic’s nuclear-weapons ambitions cannot be checked. By 2025, Tehran can start assembling these models.

These high-velocity machines require small cascades. Without an extraordin­arily lucky human-source intelligen­ce penetratio­n or sloppy Iranian telecommun­ications, American intelligen­ce services would have no ability to find them hidden in warehouses.

As the former No. 2 at the Internatio­nal Atomic Energy Agency, Olli Heinonen, has doggedly pointed out, the Iranians already may have a substantia­l secret stockpile of component parts for advanced centrifuge­s. The Obama administra­tion chose to ignore this real possibilit­y, as it chose to ignore most of the “possible military dimension” concerns that should have been at the heart of a real arms-control agreement.

To Trump’s credit, he has chosen not to ignore the deal’s counterpro­ductive sunset clauses, which make restrictio­ns on Iran temporary. He hasn’t ignored that Revolution­ary Guard bases, where we know Iran has engaged in nuclear-weapons research, are now effectivel­y off-limits to inspectors.

He is not ignoring the regime’s developmen­t of long-range ballistic missiles that only makes sense if armed with atomic warheads. He is not ignoring the strategic and moral absurdity that monies delivered to Iran under the deal abet Tehran’s imperialis­m, especially its savage campaign in Syria, which has now claimed hundreds of thousands of lives.

Stunningly, Trump is not doing what democracie­s almost always do: Punt problems down the road, where they inevitably become far worse.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States