Voters got it right
Apologies to the superfans of the acts that didn’t make the cut for the 2019 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame – you’ll get ’em next time, Todd Rundgren – but this year’s list of inductees is one of the most exciting in recent memory.
Announced Thursday, the 2019 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame class features Stevie Nicks, the Fleetwood Mac frontwoman and icon in her own right; Janet Jackson, known first as a pop star and second as an R&B innovator; Radiohead, one of the all-time indie rock greats; The Cure, whose nomination shows that the Rock Hall is finally taking the seminal genre of post-punk seriously; The Zombies, who helped define the sound of the British Invasion; Roxy Music, whose genre-bending visions helped inspire a generation of artful fol- lowers; and heavy-metal legends Def Leppard, who gained the most fan votes in the Rock Hall’s crowdsourced ballot.
After last year’s lackluster Rock Hall ceremony – its buzziest inductee being Bon Jovi, whose devoted fan base can’t sway the fact that they’re not exactly rock’s most virtuosic act – the institution needed an induction class that made us pay attention again. After all, we’re talking about a 2018 ceremony in which most of the members of Dire Straits didn’t show up, leaving the band’s bassist and keyboardists to induct themselves, an awkward moment made only stranger by the absence of the traditional inductees’ jam session that ends the show.
That changes this year, with a group of inductees that represent many of rock’s most exciting eras and evolutions over the past 50 years.
And with all due respect to each of the deserving inductees this year, we can’t help but get particularly excited over Janet Jackson and Stevie Nicks, two groundbreaking inclusions.
For Nicks, she’s making history this year as she becomes the first female artist to be inducted twice, as a member of Fleetwood Mac in 1998 and as a solo artist next year. Considering rock ’n’ roll’s history of elevating its male icons over its equally worthy female stars, it’s not a surprise that a long list of men already have been inducted twice – Michael Jackson, John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison, Neil Young, David Crosby, Stephen Stills, Graham Nash, Jeff Beck, Peter Gabriel, Curtis Mayfield, Jimmy Page, Lou Reed, Paul Simon and Rod Stewart, among others.
And for Jackson, it’s an understatement to say that her induction is overdue. The Rock Hall’s years of passing over Jackson, who has been eligible since 2007 and nominated three times, was seen as an indictment of the institution’s lack of commitment to honor R&B artists, and particularly the genre’s women. Jackson has the influential albums, the decades-spanning presence, the record-breaking charts performance and the multihyphenate status as a singer-songwriter-director-producer-choreographer – to say she’s “qualified” for the Rock Hall is an insult to her artistry.
Tack on Radiohead, true visionaries who introduced new atmospheres of sound to the genre along with new ways artists could share their art, and the Rock Hall seems to have taken a definite step toward the future. Of course, fans of Judas Priest, Outkast, Nine Inch Nails, Kate Bush, Chaka Khan and the other artists who continue to be snubbed likely will still call out the institution for being a dinosaur.
But now, with the 2019 list inspiring genuine excitement for spring’s induction ceremony, let’s recognize the Rock Hall’s wins as a reminder of why fans everywhere care about what would otherwise just be a little museum in Cleveland.