Astros’ Cole may break Yankees’ heart again
Ace pitcher rejected New York’s courtship and could inflict more pain in ALCS.
NEW YORK – He’s the one who got away for the Yankees.
The Yankees first laid eyes on him in 2008, fell deeply in love, proposed and were ready to exchange vows. But for the past 11 years and 4 months, Gerrit Cole has done nothing but break the Yankees’ hearts.
He spurned them after New York drafted him in the first round in 2008, choosing the college life at UCLA instead.
Still infatuated, and seeing an opening, the Yankees strongly started pursuing him again two years ago.
The Pirates announced they were breaking up with him, but instead of sending him to New York they traded him to the Astros.
Now, putting out their feelings for the world to see, the Yankees again are bracing themselves for heartbreak.
On Tuesday, the hottest pitcher in the game takes the mound for Houston in Game 3 of the AL Championship Series at Yankee Stadium.
In his last 22 starts, Cole is 18-0 with a 1.66 ERA and 251 strikeouts in 1621⁄3 innings, yielding a .125 batting average.
“I can’t think of anyone I’d rather pitch in this game,” Astros second baseman Jose Altuve said. “Come on, who’s better? And he loves this kind of situation.”
Really, the most intrigue in this game might not be the outcome, but how the Yankees’ fans react.
Do they taunt him, jeer him and try to rattle him like any prideful Yankees fan knowing he singlehandedly could extinguish their World Series aspirations? Or are they on their best behavior, and are
courteous, knowing they’ll have one final chance to wed this winter?
When the World Series ends, Cole will immediately become the greatest pitching prize in the land.
He’ll be a free agent, and to ensure he lives happily ever after in New York, all it costs is cold, hard cash.
“He is going to blow the doors off,” says teammate Wade Miley. “Oh, my God, you think someone will give him $300 million? How about $260 million?”
Cole, 29, is that good and is just about a lock to eclipse David Price’s recordsetting contract with the Red Sox – $217 million over seven years.
He went 20-5 with a league-leading 2.50 ERA during the regular season this year.
Will the Yankees, who desperately need an ace, shell out that kind of money just like the good old days?
How about the Rangers, who are moving into their fancy new digs?
The Cardinals, flush with cash, could have a knockout 1-2 punch with Jack Flaherty.
Hey, if Anthony Rendon doesn’t take the Nationals’ money, why not give it to Cole?
Could the Astros become the first team to have a $90 million trio of starters in Justin Verlander, Zack Greinke and Cole?
Why not an old-fashioned bidding war in Los Angeles between the Dodgers and the Angels?
Cole, with players whispering sweetnothings in his ear during the All-Star break and dropping subtle recruiting hints throughout the year, is trying his best to keep a poker face, refusing to reveal his hand.
“We’ll see,” Cole says. “That’s a question I’d be more prepared to answer in the offseason. I’m not really focused on that now.”
Those in the Astros’ clubhouse believe they know the vicinity where he’s headed, with outfielder Josh Reddick boldly predicting, “It will be west of Nevada.”
“We know he wants to be a West Coast guy,” Reddick says. “He’s a California guy, so he probably wants to be close to home. I know he mentioned Oakland a couple of times because of how he’s pitched there in the past. But that probably won’t happen. They’d have to clear the whole roster to afford him. It makes you wonder what teams are going to be able to afford him, because there’s so many teams that can’t afford somebody like that.” Predictions, anyone?
“I got the Angels,” Miley says, “and paying him at least $250 million.”
And sticking a dagger into the Yankees’ hearts one final time.
The Yankees’ attraction to Cole began more than a decade ago, convinced he had the makings to be a star. Scouting director Damon Oppenheimer was among those at the game when Cole nearly threw a no-hitter for Orange Lutheran, firing 96-mph fastballs, only for a kid named Shane Boras to break it up with an opposite-field single. That kid’s father, Scott Boras, became Cole’s adviser and agent.
The Yankees drafted him with the 28th pick in 2008 and figured it would be no problem signing him. Besides, didn’t Cole tell them he always loved the Yankees? He was the 11-year-old who sat in the front row of the 2001 World Series between the Yankees and the Diamondbacks holding a sign that read “Yankees Fan Today, Tomorrow, Forever.”
Yet when it came time to negotiate a professional contract and listen to the Yankees’ proposals, there was silence.
“Our scouting was absolutely accurate,” GM Brian Cashman says, “but the signability was completely wrong. He was going to college. They had no interest in even entertaining offers. They come from money, so he didn’t need the money, and the dad really wanted him to have the college experience. So he had the best of both worlds.”
Says Cole: “My Dad and I put an evaluation of what a UCLA education was valued at, how that compared to where I got drafted, and what the signing bonus would be. It was just too large of a discrepancy. They were really understanding, but at that point, they had just signed A.J. (Burnett) and CC (Sabathia). They were gearing up for the World Series. So they had bigger fish to fry.”
The Yankees never had a chance to redraft him three years later. The Pirates had the first pick. They spent $8 million to make sure he didn’t get away.
A decade after drafting him the first time, the Yankees thought they had another chance to finally land him, making a series of strong trade proposals to the Pirates. On Jan. 13, 2018, Pittsburgh sent him to Houston and not New York, receiving a package of Joe Musgrove, Michael Feliz, Colin Moran and Jason Martin.
The Yankees were spurned again. “Beauty is in the eye of the beholder,” Cashman said, “so obviously Pittsburgh felt their best deal was with the Astros. Some things are not meant to be.”
You know, like having the finest talent in the land on your side, instead of watching Cole terrorize your lineup.
Cole isn’t sure who’s coming to New York for his first playoff game at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, but with a day game, and the possibility of nasty shadows around home plate, he’d sure love to see sunny skies.
“New York. Cold weather,” he says. “It will feel very Octoberish. That’s when you’ve got to perform your best, in October.
“It’s the biggest stage. And it’s the most fun. I just wish it could be the postseason all of the time, but you have to work your ass off to get there.”