Chief justice proud to serve NM court
C. Shannon Bacon has served her state as a justice of the New Mexico Supreme Court since 2019 and as the chief justice for nearly two years. She is only the sixth woman to hold the top judicial leadership role in the state’s history.
She is USA TODAY’s Woman of the Year for New Mexico.
Bacon attended Creighton University in Nebraska earning a bachelor’s degree and juris doctor before returning to her hometown of Albuquerque. She continues to reside in New Mexico with her wife, Twila Firmature.
Bacon got her legal start as a clerk for the Honorable A. Joseph Alarid in the New Mexico Court of Appeals and went on to become a partner in a private legal practice in Albuquerque.
When a vacancy appeared in the Second Judicial District in New Mexico, Bacon made the decision to “put (her) hat in the ring” and join public service. She was appointed to the court by Gov. Bill Richardson and served as the presiding civil judge.
In 2019, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham appointed Bacon to the New Mexico Supreme Court. She took the oath of office on her nephews, Tristan and R.J. Bacon.
The New Mexico Supreme Court has a tradition of sharing the role of chief justice among the five presiding justices. Every two years, the justices vote to decide who will be given the chance to lead next. Bacon succeeded Justice Michael Vigil, who continues to serve the court.
The New Mexico Supreme Court, with Bacon as one of its members, has taken on many notable causes in recent years. Notably, the judiciary is partnering with other organizations to expand legal services in the state to address serious legal deserts. Three New Mexico counties have no legal providers.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the court placed a state-level moratorium on evictions to ensure New Mexicans were not left homeless. The court has also implemented the Eviction Prevention and Diversion Program to help facilitate resolutions to landlord-tenant cases before they reach the courtroom.
In late 2023, the New Mexico Supreme Court heard oral argument in the case State of New Mexico v. Board of County Commissioners for Lea County, which presented the court with the question of whether abortion is a right protected by the state constitution. The New Mexico attorney general argued the constitution does, in fact, do so. The court has yet to release its official opinion.
Question: Who paved the way for you?
Answer: Lots of people paved the way for me, but specifically I would identify the five female justices that came before me – Justice Mary Walters, Justice Pamela Minzner, Justice Petra Jimenez Maes, Justice Barbara Vigil and Justice Judith Nakamura.
What is your proudest moment, and do you have a lowest?
There’s a lot of proud moments but one that I can visualize in my head … was when I was first sworn into the (New Mexico) Supreme Court and I’m standing taking the oath on my nephews. That is a moment in time that I will never forget because of the importance of the moment. Kind of the enormity of it, but also to be there with my family and my nephews to be a part of that was a really proud moment.
Lowest moments come at, in particular as a judge, when the resolution to a legal problem really doesn’t do anybody any good. So people can come and present various arguments to you as a judge and this isn’t helping anyone. It’s not advancing anybody’s needs or goals. Those are our low moments.
Thinking about, in particular, during that foreclosure crisis, the inequity in how those cases were coming before us, I think was a low moment for any judge who was thinking about what that meant for the people who suddenly weren’t going to have a home.
What is your definition of courage?
Courage is persistence in the face of fear.
As a young person in high school, I had a soccer coach who would talk to us about obstacles are things that you perceive in your mind. And the obstacles that you perceive in your mind are created by fear of failure, fear of not doing it right, fear of, you know, fill in the blank... Which is human to have fear about the unknown or putting yourself out there in whatever way, and so to break through... that’s where that persistence or perseverance has to come in.
Is there a guiding principle or mantra that you tell yourself?
There was one that I read this morning, and I thought to myself, “I have to remember this” and it fits that mantra type of question … A cousin of mine posted this on social media and I’m not going to be able to describe who the owner of the quote is but the quote was, “Even the fiercest of birds have to fly through fog.” And I’ve been thinking about that all day today.
You think of the fierceness of birds being eagles and blue jays – blue jays are surprisingly mean – you think about, you know, birds live out in this very vulnerable world, but there’s ones that are, they’re predators. They still have to fly through fog. And so humans, you can be the toughest person in the world and you still have to walk through fog.
Who do you look up to?
There’s a lot of people I look up to, but I think in that really formative way my grandmothers without question had really profound impact on me as a young person. And then as I grew up, they were both women who did unusual things for their time.
My father’s mother (Carrie Bacon) – my grandfather died when my dad was really young, so she was a single parent raising three kids. She was a teacher. And she figured out how to put food on the table and … focus on education. And you know, that’s an amazing thing all by itself.
My mom’s mom (Ada Pick), who is the New Mexico side of my family … she started out as a teacher in a one-room schoolhouse. And she went from small northern New Mexico community to the next one. You know, she’d be that oneroom schoolteacher in Stanley then the next year she’d be in Lamy and Cimarron. And she, after she had children, earned her master’s degree and did that traveling for the summers out of state with two kids in tow. And then she became very involved in statewide education. And so she was a person as a woman who did all of these things and had a focus that women didn’t often have in that era.
And so she would (say), “You can be anything you want to be. It doesn’t matter that you’re a girl. Don’t let that enter your mind. You’re smart, you work hard, you can be president of the United States.”
“The obstacles that you perceive in your mind are created by fear of failure, fear of not doing it right, fear of, you know, fill in the blank... so to break through... that’s where that persistence or perseverance has to come in.”
What advice would you give your younger self ?
Care less about what other people think. Trust the people that you trust and listen to what they think, but don’t listen to all of that noise. And I wish my 18-year-old self knew more about that.