Community-based approach to mental health proves effective
Cochrane Library: Open access to health evidence
IN AFRICA, epidemics are associated with outbreaks like cholera and measles or HIV and tuberculosis. Mental health would possibly be the last item on anyone’s list of big health challenges.
But mental disorders, like depression, are a leading cause of mental and physical disability in sub-Saharan Africa.
There are other reasons that depression shouldn’t be ignored. The main one is that it’s known to worsen the treatment and management of HIV, TB, hypertension and diabetes.
Research shows that about 30 percent of people living with HIV are diagnosed with depression.
If left untreated there’s likely to be an increase in people developing opportunistic infections which in turn complicates HIV.
This leads to longer hospital stays, more expensive treatment and sometimes death.
But a lack of adequate mental health specialists to take care of the growing burden of psychiatric diseases in Africa complicates effective and efficient treatment.
Most African countries have a worryingly low ratio of psychiatrist or clinical psychologists to the general population.
The average is about one specialist to a million people. Zimbabwe, has 12 psychiatrists and 14 clinical psychologists for a population of 13 million. Kenya has 88 psychiatrists and 427 nurses qualified to take care of a population of 40 million.
In 2006 I led a team of researchers in Zimbabwe to test new ways of addressing mental health disorders. About 40 percent of common mental disorders consisting mainly of depression and anxiety disorders have been reported in some primary health care facilities.
We developed an approach that involves lay health workers in local communities as well as the use of digital platforms. We called it the friendship bench.
Over the last four years the initiative has reduced the waiting time for patients needing treatment. The referral rate for patients has also been significantly reduced by using text messages, WhatsApp and voice calls.
The friendship bench approach
Clients at a health facility are screened for mental illness symptoms at clinics using a locally developed tool called the Shona Symptom Questionnaire.
This first step is to establish whether someone has a mental illness, and if so what they’re suffering from.
Patients diagnosed with a mental health issue are referred to the friendship bench where they are met by a trained community counsellor who offers them counselling. The benches are located in a discreet area of the health facility.
Counsellors are trained to use local terms that patients feel comfortable with, such as Kuvhura pfungwa (opening the mind), kusimudzira (uplifting) and kusimbisa (to strengthen). Counsellors adopt a non-judgemental and practical approach, allowing the client to discuss their challenges and talk through possible solutions.
The counsellors use basic cognitive
therapy concepts, such as encouraging clients to identify what’s troubling them and to work on their attitudes and beliefs.
If the client’s mental health issue is not solved after four sessions at the wooden bench, they are referred one level up to a district health promotion officer.
We used a three pronged approach to set up the initiative. These included:
◆ speaking to the communities living near facilities to create awareness about mental health and to encourage them to own the project. We built trust by providing training and via public meetings. collecting data to support the treatment approach. developing culturally appropriate screening tools. Once we had the friendship bench approach established we made sure that we identified and analysed any gaps in the programme. We thought this would be useful for health policy and management teams wanting to set up similar programmes.
The progress
The friendship bench approach has gained attention locally as well as internationally.
It is active in over 70 primary health care facilities across Zimbabwe. Last year 30 000 adults received mental health services.
The programme has grown due to immense support from local city health authorities and the ministry of health. Over 400 lay health workers have been trained to provide the therapy.
In Zimbabwe, 80 percent of those who received therapy reported six months later that they were free of mental illness symptoms.
They also said that their quality of life and income had improved because they had become more productive.
But there are still gaps. The supervision, monitoring and strengthening of the client referrals needs to be improved to ensure that it continues to serve more people.
Governments should consider this model to deal with mental health issues.
The community initiative model has made mental health services more accessible to the people who really need them. - The Conversation. WHEN the World Health Organisation develops guidelines on the use of health care interventions, it turns to the Cochrane Library. This is a collection of databases containing high quality systemic reviews and other evidence to inform decisions about health care.
The problem is that access to these important databases costs money. In South Africa, universities and the South African Medical Research Council could access the Cochrane Library through institutional subscriptions with the library’s publishers.
But most of the country’s health care workers aren’t affiliated to universities. So the library has been inaccessible where it’s most needed - in clinical settings. Technical teams within the government and those responsible for creating policies were also left out.
Perhaps most importantly, consumers - patients who wanted to know more about medicines and possible treatments - could pay for a personal subscription. But most people can’t afford the subscription fee. Now, thanks to funding from the South African Medical Research Council (SAMRC), that’s going to change.
One of the SAMRC units, Cochrane South Africa, has procured a national licence that provides “one-click” access to the Cochrane Library for everyone in South Africa. This will provide fair, equal - and free - access to evidence-based Cochrane Reviews for all. It’s a chance for practitioners, policymakers and patients to get up-to-date, scientifically rigorous information about health care.
This is the first time a country in Africa has bought a national licence of this kind, though other low or middle-income countries such as India have already gone this route.
A valuable asset for clinicians
Being able to access up-to-date, relevant evidence is good news for any health system. It also boosts the chances of improved well-being in a society.
Systematic reviews can guide decision makers in developing policies and clinical practice guidelines. We’ve experienced this first hand. In 2007 we published a Cochrane Review about the treatment of hypertension using medications known as beta blockers.
In the decade that followed, this review has been referenced in nearly all international hypertension guidelines. It has contributed to the phasing out of the traditional approach of recommending that doctors use beta blockers as firstline treatment for the management of hypertension.
Clinicians see patients suffering from a host of illnesses every day. To keep up with the literature it’s estimated that they must read 17 articles a day. A Cochrane Review helps by providing an up-todate synthesis of all relevant research on a given topic.
This reduces the risk of practitioners cherry-picking only the studies with whose results they agree. Cochrane Reviews provide the most reliable evidence on what works, what does not work, and what requires further research. Treatments based on this information are therefore more likely to improve health outcomes.
The national licence also provides access to Cochrane Clinical Answers. These are designed to be used at the point of care, which is especially valuable for many doctors and nurses working in South Africa’s rural and remote areas.
The library works well on mobile devices, so even clinics that don’t have PCs can benefit. The national licence has been available since June and anyone in South Africa can access the library here. - The Conversation.