“Oates builds the mounting tension masterfully, crafting a fast-paced narrative that will haunt readers long after the final page.” - Publishers Weekly (starred review)
“The difference between an acceptable book and a great book is that each page of a great book begs to be turned. By that, or any other definition, Freaky Green Eyes is one of them.” - BookPage
“Moves along at the breathless pace” - BookPage
“A suspenseful story…grippingly realistic” - KLIATT
“A fast-paced, first-person thriller” - ALA Booklist
“Among this year’s most compelling fiction” - Boston Herald
“Observant family history and a developing mystery.” - Chicago Tribune