“Castle expands the story from a feel-good romance into a reflection on what makes us human.” — Publishers Weekly
“Castle’s easy prose alternates between [the characters’] perspectives and is interspersed with brief, poignant insights from the strangers they help along the way... Feel-good holiday fare.” — Kirkus Reviews
“A heartwarming, tender, and wistful look at the power of goodwill.” — Booklist
“Castle crafts relatable, endearingly flawed characters that readers will love. This book captures the magical essence of winter in New York City... It is a story that builds empathy and encourages teens to connect more with those in their own world but also with the world as a whole.” — Voice of Youth Advocates (VOYA)
“Recommended for collections where realistic fiction such as Eleanor & Park or Jennifer Castle’s other novels are popular.” — School Library Journal