“Professor Lewis’ motive is admirable, since he would like all books to have a chance, and he is right to oppose the kind of criticism which regards a work with the air of a suspicious frontier guard examining the passport of an unfriendly alien.” — The Spectator
“Lewis is provocative, tactful, biased, open-minded, old-fashioned, far-seeing, very annoying and very wise. He believes that literature exists for the joy of the reader, and that all who come between the reader and his joy… may kill the very art which they seek to protect.” — The Church Times
“This is a plea for a resolutely low-church attitude to criticism… for those in favour of happiness but distrustful of politics and the elevated disapproving mind, and his book is a charter and a liberation.” — The Tablet